JStew for a Good Young QB? Hells to the Yes.

[Gscottnc5]

No to trading JStew. Both he a Dwill seem to feed off of each other when one is playing better than the other. Their chemistry would be tough to duplicate

[Kevin Greene]

1. Deangelo is a perennial pro bowl feature back.

2. We have no QB.

3. Good RB's are much easier to draft than good QB's

4. Hurney/Fox would never have even drafted Stewart if they understood what they had in Deangelo.

5. Mike Goodson is a baller

Discuss

This is a direct and correct indictment of Hurney. I said at the time if Hurney takes Stewart then DWill (In his mind) was a failed pick and Hurney needs to go. Only teams like the Lions keep drafting a position (in their case wide receiver) over and over with your first pick.

That being said, Stewart is injury prone, has not participated in 2 training camps or very many weekly practices. You aren't going to approach the 13th pick we spent on him I believe. But with DWill, Stew is a luxury we can afford to give up for one we can't do without. A quality starting Quarter Back.

[Kevin Greene]

jason campbell right?

Campbell is a Free Agent, we can sign him (plus mush more) if we so choose with the 20 million dollars in cap space letting Peppers walk will give us.

[Sultan33g]

Campbell is a Free Agent, we can sign him (plus mush more) if we so choose with the 20 million dollars in cap space letting Peppers walk will give us.

umm I was kidding..I know he is a free agent..just trying to be funny..aahahahahahahaha...umm...sorry...:leaving:

[scpanther22]

No..

1.jstew is the power back..Dwill can do it.but we have seen lot of times were he stutter steps and gets caught behind the line..

trade peppers or sign campbell and take a QB in the 2nd or 3rd.

[Kevin Greene]

No..

1.jstew is the power back..Dwill can do it.but we have seen lot of times were he stutter steps and gets caught behind the line..

trade peppers or sign campbell and take a QB in the 2nd or 3rd.

You cannot trade Peppers. He would have to sign his FT again this offseason early enough for us to trade him. He won't like last offseason and we'll be on the hook for 20 million dollars. Peppers must walk.

[bredy087]

I want to keep DWill and JStew around as long as possible. I would rather draft or pickup a free agent QB.

[thunderraiden]

No to trading JStew. Both he a Dwill seem to feed off of each other when one is playing better than the other. Their chemistry would be tough to duplicate

You're stupid as fug dude, we won't have enough money to keep two pro-bowl running backs in a few years anyways.

[Zod]

No personal attacks please

[Sultan33g]

No personal attacks please

man these guys are either passionate about their team or passionate about being meanheadfaces

[Carolina•Pride]

Why does Philly need another running back anyway?

(to all who want Kolb)

[tarheelpride]

Agreed. Trade Stewart in the offseason and get someone like a Kolb or a 1st round pick. But, the new question is who needs a RB?

Teams I can think of:

- Kansas City: They will probably hold on to the draft pick tho

- Houston: Including them due to Slaton's fumbling problems

- Seattle: Chances are they would want to hold on to that pick to get a QB

- San Diego: Who do they have behind Tomlinson? And would you have Sproles be the feature back?

That's all I can think of. I didn't include Philly because I'd think they would want to see what they have in McCoy.

[grateflday]

I hate the thought of trading Stewart; but the reality is how long will he want to be here or vice versa would Williams want to - generally franchise type backs want to be the featured back and desire to move on. That being said I am AGAINST trading either or even Smith for a 1st round pick next year because that would just compound the mistake of trading that pick to draft E.Brown.

Now if some deal presents itself to get a young franchise type QB for Stewart I would probable jump all over that. (ie If they could have sent him to Denver for Cutler) That is just an example. I dont think that was possible because they wanted a QB in return. But some kind of deal like that I would ok with. Otherwise, keep him next year, draft a QB in round 2, bring in a Free Agent QB, then even look at drafting a QB round 1 in 2011. I just dont like the idea of trading Stewart for a 1st round next year to draft a QB.

[CRA]

Also I'd like to point out an obvious flaw in your argument:

If good RBs are so much easier to draft than QBs, then what makes you think somebody will trade a promising young QB who has shown something, for a gently used RB?

exactly. RBs are easy to find. Why trade away a promising young QB to us for an injury prone RB......

They would just keep there QB talent and draft a young RB. Look at how many teams have multiple RBs right now. The NFL is changing and QB/WRs is where the gold is.....RBs are too easy to find and replace now.