Prime Tom Brady or Prime Aaron Rodgers - Who would you want?

[Mr. Scot]

4 minutes ago, top dawg said:

Give him the weapons some of these guys had, and I'll take Marino and whip all your asses!

I will say this though: Brady's weapons weren't all-world. 

Marino was damn good.

He could make a decision in a fraction of a second and put the ball in the exact right spot.

[Scott12345]

Brady...not that close for me

[LinvilleGorge]

1 minute ago, TSLA said:

Are you going to ban me because I don’t agree with you just so you can sleep at night?  Like I said, good night dude.

The reason why everyone knows it's you every time you crawl back is because you immediately go back to your same old BS. Post stupid poo, insinuate everyone else is stupid for not agreeing with your stupid poo, then cry foul.

Good night indeed.

[Mr. Scot]

26 minutes ago, TSLA said:

Not funny to the guys who know football. 

I know football, and I find it very funny.

Wilson is a good quarterback, but he's not Aaron Rodgers good.

The only guy in the league right now that I could see placing over Aaron Rodgers is maybe Patrick Mahomes.

[Ricky Spanish]

Prime Rodgers for the following reasons:

• Brady had Belichick as his coach up until this season. Belichick is one of, if not the, greatest coaches in NFL history. I won't argue who was more important to the success of the team, but the fact that they both had each other was beneficial for everyone involved. Rodgers had Mike McCarthy up until last year. Two coaches in different stratospheres. 
• Rodgers is the most efficient QB in NFL History. He has 412 TDs to 89 interceptions (4.6 ratio). That's INSANE. For perspective, Tom brady is the second best at efficiency at 589 TDs to 191 INTs (3.04). If Aaron Rodgers threw an interception on his next 46 consecutive passes, he would still have a better career ratio than Brady.
• Rodgers is more mobile
• Rodgers has a stronger arm
• Rodgers doesn't have to deal with family drama because he doesn't talk to his. Less off field distractions.
• Brady has a weird health cult going on

Brady is the GOAT but Rodgers is the BOAT. Brady has had more overall success because he has had the benefit of playing with one of the best coaches of all time. Rodgers has had more individual success because he has dragged his teams, coaches, and organization to wins against their will at times. Rodgers said it himself "Down years for me are career years for most quarterbacks", and he's not wrong. 

[Mr. Scot]

Seeing Mike McCarthy in Dallas this year makes me wonder how Green Bay got anywhere with him.

Lotta people said it was Rodgers.

[LinvilleGorge]

10 minutes ago, Mr. Scot said:

Seeing Mike McCarthy in Dallas this year makes me wonder how Green Bay got anywhere with him.

Lotta people said it was Rodgers.

There's a lot of truth to this.

[Louie]

I think Brady is the GOAT, but I think Rodgers because of his mobility and his arm. If I’m building a franchise.

[Ricky Spanish]

12 minutes ago, Mr. Scot said:

Seeing Mike McCarthy in Dallas this year makes me wonder how Green Bay got anywhere with him.

Lotta people said it was Rodgers.

it was reported that towards the end of their time together Rodgers would straight up ignore the plays McCarthy was calling because he knew they were garbage and would call his own. 

[Mr. Scot]

1 minute ago, LinvilleGorge said:

There's a lot of truth to this.

Remember all the hype about his "coaching project"?

Didn't exactly help him, did it?

Heck I think he only ended up bringing one of those guys onto his staff.

[Basbear]

1 hour ago, Inimicus said:

Terrell Davis would like to have a word

That comment was focused on Elways' early years, he carried the team to the playoffs/superbowl with no help. Similar to that one time LeQueen did it before he went superteam BS. AI is a better example, but in NFL, its near impossible to name someone carrying a team more than Elway for his first 10 years. 

[Basbear]

Honestly Otto Graham belongs in the GOAT topic, he never gets credit. Like a better throwing Cam in the era of running and he still put up insane numbers compared to his peers. He was not human.

@Davidson Deac II or any other old timers remember him?

[Brooklyn 3.0]

TB12

[KSpan]

2 hours ago, pantherclaw said:

Brady has struggled with all world talent around him this year. Lol

Brady's also 43 years old and has struggled his way to 4600 yards and 40 TD passes. Not too shabby.