Who had the better career with the Panthers

[bababoey]

With Short's days probably numbered here, who had the better career here.  Short or Jenkins.

Short had 32 sacks, played in 1 super bowl, played in 2 pro bowls and have played a total of 5 games in the last 2 years here.  99 games total

Jenkins had 20 sacks here, played in 1 super bowl, played in 3 pro bowls and was 1st team all pro 2 times, he played a total of 5 games in 2004-2005.  85 games for the Panthers total.  Only 23 games for the Jets and 3 sacks in 3 years.

[PNW_PantherMan]

Kris was dominant but it was only for a short time.  Star was a better partner in the middle than Brenston Buckner ever was.

Who had the better career?  Probably KK cause he played more games and amassed more numbers.  But, I think Jenkins was better at his peak.

[t96]

Jenkins’ peak was much better than KK’s. KK’s was a little longer but neither was long so I’ll give the edge to Kris.

[Zaximus]

Kris also had Peppers and Rucker around him too.   

[bababoey]

To me Jenkins was a far more talented player but he would turn it off almost as much as he would turn it on.  When he played hard he might be one of the best I have ever see play but so many times he would just give a half assed effort.

At least Short played hard and gave an effort.  He didn't have half the talent that Jenkins had around him but he always gave the effort.

[Paintballr]

Funny how people forget the bitching they did on Kris on here back in the day. 
 

Kris was great when he wanted to be, but towards the end of his time here he turned it off and checked out. People here was happy he was gone and were basically saying we ripped off the jets for a 3rd round and 5th round draft pick (we used them on Charles Godfrey and Gary Barnidge)

 

KK was a surprise and def benefited from playing with Star. I’d say both had similiar careers here and impacted their spot about the same 

[thefuzz]

KK had the better career, Kris was the more dominate player (at his peak).

[philw5289]

Different types of DT’s. KK was nearly unstoppable on the super bowl run 

[hepcat]

I think KK was better primarily because he wasn't a drama queen and by and large kept his weight under control. Jenkins hated playing in Charlotte and couldn't keep his weight under control. 

[Car123]

Kris. KK had one great season and a bunch of average ones.

[NJPanthers12]

Some people forget how dominant Kris was. KK at his best wast anywhere near the player Jenkins was. I think Jenkins should be in the hall of honor. There was a two year stretch where he was the best DT in football and every bit as good of a player as Peppers.

[Basbear]

Off the mind, its Jenkins... But looking at those stats shows KK. Im going with what I member,

[electro's horse]

i remember belichick saying once that 02-03 jenkins was the best defender in the nfl

[electro's horse]

did you just call an argentinian a greaseball?