When it is all said and done, who will have had the better career?

[Jeremy Igo]

If you had to make a prediction today, would you say Shaq Thompson or Jeremy Chinn will have had the better career?

[top dawg]

We haven't really seen anything from Chinn yet, so to pick him at this point is just optimistic wishful thinking. Let's see what he has to offer first! For all of the great expectations for Shaq, he's at least proven that he is a legit NFL-caliber player.

[t96]

Shaq. That could change but Chinn is a 2nd rounder who has never played an NFL game...

[WarPanthers89]

Chinn. He will be on the field a lot quicker and much more than Shaq was in his first 4 years. This coaching staff wants to develop young talent, and not sit them because they have an obsession with vets. 

[Tbe]

I’m assuming a lot, but I’ll say Chinn.

Shaq’s prime years are almost over and he hasn’t really seen that much playing time.

Chinn will likely start from day one. He’ll prob suck his first year, but he has a ton of time to get better.

[Ship]

Chinn has that vibe of a special player. We’ll see. 

[bababoey]

26 minutes ago, Tbe said:

I’m assuming a lot, but I’ll say Chinn.

Shaq’s prime years are almost over and he hasn’t really seen that much playing time.

Chinn will likely start from day one. He’ll prob suck his first year, but he has a ton of time to get better.

Shaq is 26 and does not have the concussion problems that Luke had.  His prime years should be the next 4 or 5.  

I have not even seen Chinn practice so I only know about him from highlights on tape and the combine.

At least I know Shaq is a good solid LB so I would say him until I at least see Chinn play.

[Waldo]

Do they even play the same position? Seriously waiting to see how they play Chinn.

The bar for Chinn to pass Shaq is pretty low at this time but both have potential to be good in the new D going forward. I'm hopeing both live up to their potential.

 

[Sean Payton's Vicodin]

im optimistic about chinn however i realize that this guy could very well be another hurney 2nd round flop. he's either gonna be a superstar or flame out in 3 years. i'll play it safe and go with shaq.

 

[Wolfcop]

Chinn has that Thomas Davis feel to him to me. I will gamble and go with him. 

[Icege]

Regardless of who has the better career, I'm just hoping to see both have stellar careers with the Panthers. :D

[MasterAwesome]

What a random thread...you want us to try and project the career of a 2nd round rookie who hasn’t taken a snap? It’s hard enough to do that even for Shaq.

[AggieLean]

Going with the safe bet here. Shaq.

[Cookie Lyon]

"Take it on the Chinn, Shaq!"