Saquon Barkley is an all-time talent and better than McCaffrey

[MafiaBills]

He's been Shula'd 

[LinvilleGorge]

On 11/26/2019 at 9:39 AM, PghPanther said:

I don't know anything about Barkley's play as I haven't seen him in action...........but as a person posting here who is accused of "racism" I will tell you that I'm not impressed with CMC........I think he is actually overrated.

He only impresses me in the open field............and just about any running back can impress me there..........did you see the game last night and which the Baltimore RB's powered through all those tackles with speed?

If CMC was just as fast but bigger in size it might make him elite.............as it is, I think he's going to pay a heavy price in physical abuse over time if they keep trying to play him between the tackles........or play him in too many snaps.

and for pass blocking?.......he looks like a kid out there against DTs........

The thing is that CMC creates an "open field" because he's so shifty. You almost never see a defender get a clean shot at him and he almost always picks up extra yards via shiftiness instead of being a human bulldozer.  I guess you didn't think much of Barry Sanders?

[Ricky Spanish]

38 minutes ago, LinvilleGorge said:

The thing is that CMC creates an "open field" because he's so shifty. You almost never see a defender get a clean shot at him and he almost always picks up extra yards via shiftiness instead of being a human bulldozer.  I guess you didn't think much of Barry Sanders?

Warrick Dunn did the same thing back in the day. He was even smaller than CMC and he was an in between the tackles runner. 

The fact he's not trying to run people over is only going to lengthen his career, not shorten it. Fewer bigger hits means less wear and tear on his body. Bulldozing backs really don't last long in the NFL these days. 

[PootieNunu]

On 11/26/2019 at 11:39 AM, PghPanther said:

I don't know anything about Barkley's play as I haven't seen him in action...........but as a person posting here who is accused of "racism" I will tell you that I'm not impressed with CMC........I think he is actually overrated.

He only impresses me in the open field............and just about any running back can impress me there..........did you see the game last night and which the Baltimore RB's powered through all those tackles with speed?

If CMC was just as fast but bigger in size it might make him elite.............as it is, I think he's going to pay a heavy price in physical abuse over time if they keep trying to play him between the tackles........or play him in too many snaps.

and for pass blocking?.......he looks like a kid out there against DTs........

Do you create posts just to have the worst takes possible? CMC is our whole offense and teams still cant stop him. The teams playing against the Ravens have to guard Jackson and the RB. Nobody is worried about Kyle Allen running the ball on them.

[MHS831]

what kind of twit starts a thread like this?

[PootieNunu]

1 minute ago, MHS831 said:

what kind of twit starts a thread like this?

The kind that gets tired of our players being put down for the new hot thing obviously. CMC is an amazing RB but people just look at the color of his skin and move on to the next hot thing. Barkley was touted as the next walter payton or something.

[MHS831]

Just now, PootieNunu said:

The kind that gets tired of our players being put down for the new hot thing obviously. CMC is an amazing RB but people just look at the color of his skin and move on to the next hot thing. Barkley was touted as the next walter payton or something.

Who gives a crap?  Barkley is a heck of a player.  So is CMC.  Only a child starts a thread like this--who the hell cares?

[PootieNunu]

34 minutes ago, MHS831 said:

Who gives a crap?  Barkley is a heck of a player.  So is CMC.  Only a child starts a thread like this--who the hell cares?

Nobody in Carolina I guess we just sit back and sip our wine and let the rest of the league mock us. Barkley was said to be the best RB prospect since Adrian Peterson, meanwhile CMC couldn't make it in the NFL because he couldn't run between the tackles.

If we drafted Barkley it would have been the same poo, only difference he is in NY.

[jfra78]

26 minutes ago, PootieNunu said:

Nobody in Carolina I guess we just sit back and sip our wine and let the rest of the league mock us. Barkley was said to be the best RB prospect since Adrian Peterson, meanwhile CMC couldn't make it in the NFL because he couldn't run between the tackles.

If we drafted Barkley it would have been the same poo, only difference he is in NY.

Why do Panther fans put so much stock in what other fan bases think about our team, or even what the national media thinks?  

[MHS831]

42 minutes ago, PootieNunu said:

Nobody in Carolina I guess we just sit back and sip our wine and let the rest of the league mock us. Barkley was said to be the best RB prospect since Adrian Peterson, meanwhile CMC couldn't make it in the NFL because he couldn't run between the tackles.

If we drafted Barkley it would have been the same poo, only difference he is in NY.

Mock scoreboards--not players. Stats and personal stats are not important---

[PootieNunu]

41 minutes ago, jfra78 said:

Why do Panther fans put so much stock in what other fan bases think about our team, or even what the national media thinks?  

Because that directly correlates to why some people are saying that Cam wants to leave because we are not a major market team. How will we ever get any respect with fans that think like this? Lets just accept the mediocrity and relish in it I guess...

It was fine when people were slamming us for picking CMC so high in the draft now he is paying dividends lets not celebrate this at all

[jfra78]

23 minutes ago, PootieNunu said:

Because that directly correlates to why some people are saying that Cam wants to leave because we are not a major market team. How will we ever get any respect with fans that think like this? Lets just accept the mediocrity and relish in it I guess...

It was fine when people were slamming us for picking CMC so high in the draft now he is paying dividends lets not celebrate this at all

I honestly don't think Cam cares 

[KaseKlosed]

No NFL gm is going to draft cmc over Barkley given the chance. You guys seriously need to stop riding cmcs nuts so much. Next cmc will be the best RB of all time. 

[Mikey818]

9 hours ago, KaseKlosed said:

No NFL gm is going to draft cmc over Barkley given the chance. You guys seriously need to stop riding cmcs nuts so much. Next cmc will be the best RB of all time. 

Cmc is the better player. Barkley has too many negative plays. Cmc runs better routes much better receiver. Any Gm would be an idiot to not draft cmc knowing  what he brings