Thoughts on a Josh Rosen Draft Day Trade

[Cpt slay a ho]

Sure for a late rounder

[DamnItJake!]

Seriously!! wtf!! Rosen!! The dude sucked at UCLA!! I would keep Allen over him!! He is Clausen 2.0!! These QB desperate threads need to stop!

[kungfoodude]

2 hours ago, Carl Spackler said:

How do you explain his ability to like, uh, you know, complete deep passes if his arm is as weak as Allen’s

I think you are kind of fitting the description of the post I was replying to.

[Panthercougar68]

5th or 6th round pick. Problem is that QB tag makes him more valuable even if the player was trash.

[ncfan]

8 hours ago, Carl Spackler said:

Not very easily picked or defensed as it were  https://youtu.be/v7lwAImrSb8

Against bottom of the barrel guys who are probably 3rd string, PS, or cut from the Steelers now.  And again, the fade air under it.

He can hit libs like that.  Its just every other throw is finesse, not hard, a lot of air.  

His throws in the open field 20-30 yards have a lot of air under them and are slow.  Giving defenders time.  While Rosen's are on a rope.

There's a reason why Rosen didnt make it out of the top 10 and every team passed on Grier atleast 3 times

[Carl Spackler]

9 hours ago, kungfoodude said:

I think you are kind of fitting the description of the post I was replying to.

You’ve certainly not proven yourself to be unbiased in this, that’s for sure. Let’s hope the front office isn’t stupid enough to trade for Rosen.

[Carl Spackler]

3 hours ago, ncfan said:

Against bottom of the barrel guys who are probably 3rd string, PS, or cut from the Steelers now.  And again, the fade air under it.

He can hit libs like that.  Its just every other throw is finesse, not hard, a lot of air.  

His throws in the open field 20-30 yards have a lot of air under them and are slow.  Giving defenders time.  While Rosen's are on a rope.

There's a reason why Rosen didnt make it out of the top 10 and every team passed on Grier atleast 3 times

What’s the reason Paxton Lynch didn’t make it past the first round? 

[Carl Spackler]

The “there’s a reason he was passed up X times” argument is the most played out, irrational reasoning especially since the best QB of all time was passed up until the 6th round.
 

Guess there’s a reason Spergon Wynn went higher?

[BrianS]

Trade for him?  No, I wouldn't.

If he is cut, would I bring him in as a camp arm on a no guarantees contract to see if Norv could save him?  Maybe.

[kungfoodude]

27 minutes ago, Carl Spackler said:

You’ve certainly not proven yourself to be unbiased in this, that’s for sure. Let’s hope the front office isn’t stupid enough to trade for Rosen.

I don't particularly care if we traded for him or not but your characterization of no one saying Grier had a weak arm was complete BS. It was one of the common knocks on him coming out in the draft, had you paid attention. 

 

As for Grier, I was not a fan of drafting him because I do not think he is capable of being more than a 2nd or 3rd string QB. He hasn't proved me wrong so far. It's cool to have someone local who was a Panthers fan but maybe not with a 3rd round draft pick.

All that said, fug it, start him against New Orleans. I have seen enough of Allen.

[Icege]

Hard pass

[ncfan]

1 hour ago, Carl Spackler said:

What’s the reason Paxton Lynch didn’t make it past the first round? 

Because he was just a big raw prospect and Elway picked him.

 

Congrats you picked the one pure bust from the 1st round the last couple years.

 

Now you want me to list all the 4th rounders (which Grier essentially was) that didnt pan out as starters in the league.  Ill give you a hint, the list of the one that panned out is a Lot shorter than then the ammount of 1st rounders that ended up being bust

[onmyown]

Man you guys must really hate Allen for some otherworldly, unknown reason if you’d rather Even discuss trading a second  round pick for Rosen lol wtf

[Carl Spackler]

6 hours ago, ncfan said:

Because he was just a big raw prospect and Elway picked him.

 

Congrats you picked the one pure bust from the 1st round the last couple years.

 

Now you want me to list all the 4th rounders (which Grier essentially was) that didnt pan out as starters in the league.  Ill give you a hint, the list of the one that panned out is a Lot shorter than then the ammount of 1st rounders that ended up being bust

lol how long are you giving Rosen before calling him a bust, 10 years?