Do you want Cam to start @49ers Oct 27th.

[BurnMe53]

For me it depends.    If we are 3-3 Id say yes , if he's ready and healthy.  But if 4-2 Id so no. I'd ride with the the hot hand at QB as long as hes winning. 

[Tepper's Chest Hair]

5 minutes ago, SmokinwithWilly said:

Here's the bigger question though. If he starts and looks bad, how long do you wait to pull him or do you? Do you just accept a loss to let Cam work through it, or do you put KA in and try for the win if it's still close?

At the same time, they could just give Cam the Kyle Allen play calling if he looks bad.

Just tell him to hand it off to CMC every play.

[SBiii]

3 hours ago, Jeremy Igo said:

Pretend for a moment that Cam is cleared medically to play at San Fran. Do you play him?

 

Facing a great defense, away on the west coast, after a bye (Ron sucks after byes). 

 

Or would you rather wait a week.

 

If he's truly 100% what's the rationale for holding him out?

Afraid he will get hurt again?

If so, what other games on the schedule this year are deemed too risky for him to play in?

Cam gets to play the easy games and sacrifice the backup in the tough ones?

Pretty amazing concept there.

[trueblade]

17 minutes ago, Tepper's Chest Hair said:

At the same time, they could just give Cam the Kyle Allen play calling if he looks bad.

Just tell him to hand it off to CMC every play.

Cam did have KA playcalling, at least in Week 1. CMC had the same basic number of touches in Week 1 (29) as he did in Weeks 3 (27) and 5 (25). 

It'll be interesting to see how this week goes. The last Bucs game was CMC's season low for touches.

[Seoul_Panther]

Prior to the browns game Bosa had 1 sack all season. The Browns had Greg Robinson at LT.

Bosa is no better than Chandler Jones, JJ Watt or Calais Campbell our last 3 opponents.

Cam is either ready or he's not. Whatever happens he'd better realise that if he starts he can't roll out injury excuses again.

[catnip]

Let's see how the team does in London before making the call on Cam .  If we win and Allen plays decent we stay the course and allow Cam to get back in game shape and fully healed .  The team has played well the last three weeks with Allen at the QB so lets keep it up .

[mc52beast]

It’s hard to say. If Allen wins vs TB he’s 4-0 this season. Do you insert Cam and risk messing up the chemistry?

Im thinking that Ron won’t want to put Cam in his first playing time since the Bucs against that 9er front. If he’s 100% and has gotten enough reps I play him vs the Titans.

[ForJimmy]

He needs to be 100% and fully participating in practices leading up to the game. Can’t afford much rust against that defense...

[TheMaulClaw]

44 minutes ago, SBiii said:

If he's truly 100% what's the rationale for holding him out?

Afraid he will get hurt again?

If so, what other games on the schedule this year are deemed too risky for him to play in?

Cam gets to play the easy games and sacrifice the backup in the tough ones?

Pretty amazing concept there.

It's an amazing concept because the back up wins.

[Palmetto]

It'll be nice if we can keep winning and Cam comes back around thanks giving 

 

[Seoul_Panther]

Just a reminder that 49ers have wins over the Bucs, Bengals, Steelers and Browns who have a cumulative 5-15 record 

  Right now this looks like a game against a playoff team, but by the end of the season we may look back and say we should have won that.

 No doubt they are a form team on the road but this is not the team some people make them out to be. Their game against LAR this week may be their first real test.

[cookinbrak]

1 hour ago, Jeremy Igo said:

He was out of the boot and at practice yesterday. He could be ready in 3 weeks.

At practice and practicing are 2 different animals.

[SBiii]

Just now, TheMaulClaw said:

It's an amazing concept because the back up wins.

Which games on the rest of the sched do we feel it is OK for Cam to play in?

Bucs  (Not avail. London game, Cam's foot not ready to fly/stand)

Bye

@ 49'ers  (OUT.  Too risky, some meanies on their D)

Titans  (Prob OK to play assuming he is for sure 100%)

@ Packers  (Too cold? Shud prob stay home)

Falcons  (Prob OK? They arent too good this year)

@ Saints  (OUT.  Mean guys on D who dont like Cam, too risky)

Redskins  (Def OK.)

@ Falcons  (Maybe OK? Astroturf might be bad for his foot)

Seahawks  (Prob not?  Chancellor & Clowney are very mean) 

@ Colts  (Prob OK.  However, astroturf field is a concern)

Saints  (Maybe?  Depends on record at the time)

Looks like Colts, Redskins, Falcons (2) and Titans games he should be OK.  Def should be held out of Packers, Saints and probably Seahawks.  Last Saints game TBD depending on how season is going....if not making playoffs hold him out to save him for the future.

[The Lobo]

100% healthy, yes