Is McCaffrey already our best non-QB offensive player in franchise history?

[t96]

I think the argument is him vs Smith. Smith was a complete beast but even at his best was he as good as McC has been?

[firefox1234]

We need some big game wins like playoff wins to cement him but he is getting there in my opinion.

[Mr. Scot]

Don't know, but it's a valid discussion topic.

Still gotta see how long he lasts.

[electro's horse]

in 2005 smith led the league in receptions, yards, and receiving TDs

[!stUp]

[JARROD]

We will see how long he lasts at that pace.

it was nice to see Bonnafon run so effectively.

 

[Carl Spackler]

Absolutely not, but he has the potential. 13 years still trumps 2.3 years 

[mc52beast]

Will be the best if Ron and Norv dont bury him before he sees five seasons

[bLACKpANTHER]

 

[PantherFanInPhilly]

He will be.

[Black&BlueBubba]

I think Steve smith would have something to say about that.  
he has had a nice start.  But he has a while to over take 89

[OneBadCat]

That's tough.  CMC is his own phenomenon but Smith is one of the greatest WR to play the game and was never utilized to the effect that CMC is being used right now.  He also plays RB so the dude has so many more opportunities to touch the ball.  

But considering the way CMC seems to be able to carry the team you could probably say so. But jesus christ Scarlett and Bonafon need to play more.

[WarPanthers89]

He’s not above Smith but is already #2 in my book and he hasn’t finished his third season yet. He could be mvp this year if he keeps it up. 

[Black&BlueBubba]

1 minute ago, PantherFanInPhilly said:

He will be.