Daley at LT?

[Mr. Scot]

7 minutes ago, Pantherxtreme said:

Yes I know Gettleman is the goat GM. He inherited a team void of talent and poor coaching and his smarts led us to a 17-1 season and Super Bowl appearance. 

See Toomers post above.

With Gettleman-Rivera, we won.

With Hurney-Fox and/or Hurney-Rivera, we win a little bit early but get worse the longer it goes on. 

It's not a difficult pattern to see, and all the spin and excuses in the world won't change it.

[LinvilleGorge]

Oh great, Hurney vs. Gettleman. Again.

People are blind if they can't admit both deserved to be fired. I'm still personally shocked that Tepper decided to hang onto Hurney.

[Pantherxtreme]

I'll see how this season turns out before I give any credence to that so-called pattern. 

[Mr. Scot]

4 minutes ago, Pantherxtreme said:

I'll see how this season turns out before I give any credence to that so-called pattern. 

Oh sure. It's not like Rivera's in his ninth year as a coach, Hurney's in his fifteenth season as a GM or they've already had four seasons together.

Heck, we hardly know anything about them 

[Pantherxtreme]

4 minutes ago, Mr. Scot said:

Oh sure. It's not like Rivera's in his ninth year as a coach, Hurney's in his fifteenth season as a GM or they've already had four seasons together.

Heck, we hardly know anything about them 

Yes maybe we should get some Steelers retread you keep blabbing about they look awesome this year. 

[MasterAwesome]

Hurney 2.0: 9-11

Gettleman 2.0: 7-13

Hurney 2.0 > Gettleman 2.0 (or less sucky)

Hurney inherited a 6-10 team from Gettleman and got them to 11-5 in his first season back.

It’s pretty easy to paint any narrative you want when you ignore nuance.

[Waldo]

7 minutes ago, MasterAwesome said:

Hurney 2.0: 9-11

Gettleman 2.0: 7-13

Hurney 2.0 > Gettleman 2.0 (or less sucky)

Hurney inherited a 6-10 team from Gettleman and got them to 11-5 in his first season back.

It’s pretty easy to paint any narrative you want when you ignore nuance.

The 11-5 team was a Gettleman team. Hurney came in at training camp.

We will be a better organization with both behind us regardless.

[raz]

we arguing about 2 poor gm's and not the poor coach?  rr does not get a pass for all his boneheaded decisions because of gm's

[Toomers]

5 minutes ago, MasterAwesome said:

Hurney 2.0: 9-11

Gettleman 2.0: 7-13

Hurney 2.0 > Gettleman 2.0 (or less sucky)

Hurney inherited a 6-10 team from Gettleman and got them to 11-5 in his first season back.

It’s pretty easy to paint any narrative you want when you ignore nuance.

Or facts? 

  Hurney took over an 11-5 team. The ONLY moves he made actually hurt the team for the 2017 season. Gano/Butker and KB. One cost us an extra 3M(that year) and we went into playoffs with a practice squad at WR. 

Gettleman took over the 2nd worst team in the NFL with hug cap issues. And has still managed to stay within 2 games with complete opposite circumstances. 

  I guess nuance is whatever you want it to be? 

[Pantherxtreme]

7 minutes ago, Toomers said:

Or facts? 

  Hurney took over an 11-5 team. The ONLY moves he made actually hurt the team for the 2017 season. Gano/Butker and KB. One cost us an extra 3M(that year) and we went into playoffs with a practice squad at WR. 

Gettleman took over the 2nd worst team in the NFL with hug cap issues. And has still managed to stay within 2 games with complete opposite circumstances. 

  I guess nuance is whatever you want it to be? 

Cam had his best games after KB got traded try again. 

[Mr. Scot]

46 minutes ago, Pantherxtreme said:

Yes maybe we should get some Steelers retread you keep blabbing about they look awesome this year. 

That guy has more Super Bowls than losing seasons over a 20 year span, so yeah I'll take that.

Here's a challenge for you: Convince me that Hurney and Rivera are a great combination using only their win-loss record (reminder: 2017 doesn't go in their column since her knee wasn't hired till training camp).

Aaaaaannnnd...Go!

[Mr. Scot]

34 minutes ago, Toomers said:

Or facts? 

  Hurney took over an 11-5 team. The ONLY moves he made actually hurt the team for the 2017 season. Gano/Butker and KB. One cost us an extra 3M(that year) and we went into playoffs with a practice squad at WR. 

Gettleman took over the 2nd worst team in the NFL with hug cap issues. And has still managed to stay within 2 games with complete opposite circumstances. 

  I guess nuance is whatever you want it to be? 

To be fair and accurate (in both directions) Marty didn't initiate the Benjamin trade. Brandon Beane did.

[Pantherxtreme]

5 minutes ago, Mr. Scot said:

That guy has more Super Bowls than losing seasons over a 20 year span, so yeah I'll take that.

Here's a challenge for you: Convince me that Hurney and Rivera are a great combination using only their win-loss record (reminder: 2017 doesn't go in their column since her knee wasn't hired till training camp).

Aaaaaannnnd...Go!

The eyeball test this team is as deep and talented as I can remember. Again if we get solid Qb play, I feel we can challenge anyone in the NFC this season. 

[Mr. Scot]

1 minute ago, Pantherxtreme said:

The eyeball test this team is as deep and talented as I can remember. Again if we get solid Qb play, I feel we can challenge anyone in the NFC this season. 

Again, using only their win-loss record. Your opinion isnt part of that.