Which of these stat lines is better?

[Bartin]

2 minutes ago, Mage said:

What?

“QB B is actually...Cam Newton's first three road starts”

The two games you cited were home games so they wouldn’t be a part of the stat the OP put up.

[Jon Snow]

3-0 beats 0-3 always.

[t96]

Obviously Allen’s is better but it’s really pointless to compare the two, the teams around them were completely different, the opponents were completely different, the overall situations were completely different and it’s a tiny sample size. 

[arbnranger]

6 minutes ago, GOOGLE JIM BOB COOTER said:

QB A: 72 of 118 (61.0% completion), 1,033 yards, 3 TDs, 5 interceptions; 23 rushes for 100 yards, 4 TDs, 2 fumbles, 0-3

QB B: 49 of 79 (62% completion), 564 yards, 3 TDs, 2 interceptions; 3 rushes for 5 yards, 2-1

2-1 beats 0-3 every time. matt moore owns

Haha...decent post 

[Mage]

4 hours ago, Bartin said:

“QB B is actually...Cam Newton's first three road starts”

The two games you cited were home games so they wouldn’t be a part of the stat the OP put up.

Oh, gotcha.

Makes this thread even more pointless. 

[JawnyBlaze]

Well since wins are a team stat not an individual player’s stat you can drop that from the comparison. It’s close. I’ll take an interception over a lost fumble since an interception usually puts them much further down the field.
 

Hard to really compare since one had only one WR that should even be in the NFL and an ok defense and the other has a comparatively stacked supporting offensive cast and a defense playing lights out. 

[Peppers90 NC]

He did, had 400+ first two games.

 

although not sure if the second one was at home or not, I believe it was

[Sam Mills Fan]

16 hours ago, EgoDogg said:

Look at the teams around those players, too.

2011 was right after going 2-14. Legedu Naanee was also our #2 receiver. This thread is one of the most cherry-picked threads I've seen.

Not really. I'm not saying Kyle Allen is better than Cam, no one is. Only insecure Cam fanboys are thinking other people are saying that. I'm just sick of people saying Kyle Allen is just Matt Moore when eyeball test and his stats show he's clearly much more.

[Sam Mills Fan]

13 hours ago, GOOGLE JIM BOB COOTER said:

chris weinke went 1-2 in his first 3 games. the record speaks for itself. 1-2 > 0-3 and let me tell you something those records sure were reflective of individual impact and predictive of future success/failure

Another insecure child. No one is saying Kyle Allen is having a better start to his career than Cam Newton. Just that the insecure Camboys that are trying to poo-poo Kyle Allen's stats should see they compare very favorably to Cam's.

[trueblade]

15 hours ago, bull123 said:

Cams first game in Phoenix was really exciting...but we lost

Largely because Patrick Peterson had a punt return for a TD. It's part of the reason I've never been a fan of #QBWinz.

[panthers55]

As long as we keep winning I don't care who is playing or who is best. Winning cures all woes. 

[EgoDogg]

2 hours ago, Sam Mills Fan said:

Not really. I'm not saying Kyle Allen is better than Cam, no one is. Only insecure Cam fanboys are thinking other people are saying that. I'm just sick of people saying Kyle Allen is just Matt Moore when eyeball test and his stats show he's clearly much more.

The truth is you can't anoint him or crucify him after 3 starts. He's done everything you can ask for him as a passer filling in for Cam. He hasn't made any bad decisions throwing and his biggest issue is fumbling, which can be corrected a lot easier than reading defenses. I'm saying just because he had more success (with a better supporting cast) than Cam did in his first 3 road starts doesn't mean squat for what type of player he'll be long-term, and as more tape is available.

I don't think this needs saying, but I will anyways. I absolutely love being confident in having a backup like Kyle Allen. I haven't had faith in a backup QB coming in the game for a LONG time. I don't have an opinion on how he'll be long term. I'm not saying he'll be the next Brady or the next Weinke. He's going to be the next Kyle Allen, and it's very promising what he's shown so far. But I stand by my initial statement that those comparisons don't mean anything.

[kungfoodude]

2 hours ago, Sam Mills Fan said:

Not really. I'm not saying Kyle Allen is better than Cam, no one is. Only insecure Cam fanboys are thinking other people are saying that. I'm just sick of people saying Kyle Allen is just Matt Moore when eyeball test and his stats show he's clearly much more.

I mean....for calling out "insecure Cam fanboys"......you did start this thread, correct?