Panthers Mt. Rushmore

[Happy Panther]

https://www.stadiumtalk.com/s/nfl-mount-rushmores-by-team-5b54e4a0e3504da4?utm_campaign=nflrushmore-87deef4111a64000&utm_source=twi&utm_medium=cpc&utm_content=816257

Hard to argue with that...Olsen might be the fifth? Edit: The article argues Thomas Davis would be the fifth.

[Squirrel]

Smitty peppers and luke. no to Cam. 

[trueblade]

It feels like Sam Mills has to be on there, but I have no clue who to take down for his spot.

[CBDellinger]

No Sam Mills?  I mean they put the guy in bronze outside the stadium.  His words are the mantra, "keep pounding."

Fail.

[countryboi]

3 minutes ago, Squirrel said:

Smitty peppers and luke. no to Cam. 

Cam is the best QB in Panther history, he is just as deserving as anyone on this list. few injuries and yall forget everything he has done. 

[Pantha-kun]

Currently : Steve Smith, Julius Peppers, Cam Newton, Sam Mills III (in that order) 

Future? : Possibly Luke, Smith, Peppers, Cam (Could be replaced by the first QB who gets us a SB title) ,  (someone else, ex. CMC, DJ )

[Happy Panther]

1 minute ago, Pantha-kun said:

Currently : Steve Smith, Julius Peppers, Sam Mills III 

Future? : Possibly Luke, Smith, Peppers, (not sure who goes here)

CMC...

[Happy Panther]

3 minutes ago, CBDellinger said:

No Sam Mills?  I mean they put the guy in bronze outside the stadium.  His words are the mantra, "keep pounding."

Fail.

He was great but only played for us for 3 years. He was a Saint for 9 years.

[TheRumGone]

Peppers Cam Smitty Luke and TD

those are the greatest Panthers.

[Pantha-kun]

Just now, Happy Panther said:

CMC...

its really early to say that when hes still on his rookie deal but i put him in as a future possibility

[Pantha-kun]

Just now, TheRumGone said:

Peppers Cam Smitty Luke and TD

those are the greatest Panthers.

i cant argue too much there tbh. I'd put Smith and Luke before Cam though.

[Pantha-kun]

I don't think you can leave Cam off the board due to him bringing us our single best franchise season, being the franchises only MVP, holding numerous franchise QB records, and being the most polarizing figure in team history. 

You could argue someone could take his spot in the future I guess, but you'd need a Nick Foles like situation for that to happen, or someone that starts for an equivalent time period with better stats/wins/accolades.

[TheRumGone]

Just now, Pantha-kun said:

i cant argue too much there tbh. I'd put Smith and Luke before Cam though.

I think I’d put Cam over Luke simply because of the position they play. I know Luke is up there with GOAT mlbs but the qb position is more important, face of franchise.

NFL MVP > DPY

he quarterbacked the greatest Panther season ever. He gets the nod over Luke if I had to choose. Smitty is the greatest Panther player in our history over Pep just because he stayed with us all but 2 years of his career. They both impacted the team at the same level imo.

[SmittysLawnGuy]

I got Kyle Allen, Brad Hoover, CMC and the new kicker (forgot his name).

Honorable mention

Casey, Olsen, Shockey, Gross, Kueckly, Kalil (both), Delhome, Kerry Collins, Pickles, Testeverde, and Brandon Weger (well maybe). I'm leaving off quite a few Panther Heroes but they all can't get the nod.

Come@me.