Newton Vs Luck

[Devil Doc]

I hate when I have this debate, that no one ever counts Newton Rushing, they only count his throws. The NFL has Multi Threat QB's, this is not the days of the old of Pocket QBs, you have to add the Rushing stats. 

[LinvilleGorge]

Luck retired. The debate is over.

[Peppers90 NC]

definitely thread worthy, definitely

[Devil Doc]

Just now, Peppers90 NC said:

definitely thread worthy, definitely

It is.... I am tired of people thinking all a QB does is throw. 

[Peppers90 NC]

3 minutes ago, Devil Doc said:

It is.... I am tired of people thinking all a QB does is throw. 

most people dont think that, so why worry about the few that do?

[Seltzer]

OP makes good point, don't know if it's thread-worthy but still.

It's the same as not counting receiving yards/TD's for a RB 

Or not counting rushing yards/TD's for a WR

It's a not-so-subtle way of trying to discredit Newton... if Cam retires tomorrow he's arguably the greatest redzone rusher of all time, and that doesn't even count his passing acumen.

It's frustrating, but at this point, you just have to look past it... 

I don't blame Andrew Luck one bit, but Cam would be getting killed today had he done the same thing... 

[4Corners]

“I hate when I have this debate”

creates thread about it

#HuddleLogic

[Devil Doc]

3 minutes ago, Seltzer said:

OP makes good point, don't know if it's thread-worthy but still.

It's the same as not counting receiving yards/TD's for a RB 

Or not counting rushing yards/TD's for a WR

It's a not-so-subtle way of trying to discredit Newton... if Cam retires tomorrow he's arguably the greatest redzone rusher of all time, and that doesn't even count his passing acumen.

It's frustrating, but at this point, you just have to look past it... 

I don't blame Andrew Luck one bit, but Cam would be getting killed today had he done the same thing... 

I agree.. its the same when they don't count return yards either. 

 

[Devil Doc]

1 minute ago, 4Corners said:

“I hate when I have this debate”

creates thread about it

#HuddleLogic

Yep, because it is not a debate here, it is a debate from outside fans. Didn't you get the memo?

[ellis]

ICYMI. 

 

 

[Carl Spackler]

2 minutes ago, ellis said:

ICYMI. 

 

 

thanks Bull Moose, much more of a mild personality in here

[Devil Doc]

7 minutes ago, ellis said:

ICYMI. 

 

 

My Thread was just a post to insert your video @ellis. Looks like it worked. 

 

[ellis]

Sorry? 

[NAS]

46 minutes ago, Devil Doc said:

I hate when I have this debate, that no one ever counts Newton Rushing, they only count his throws. The NFL has Multi Threat QB's, this is not the days of the old of Pocket QBs, you have to add the Rushing stats. 

How old are you?  LOL