The Too Early 53 ***

[SetfreexX]

QB-

Newton / Grier

HB- 

CMC / Scarlett / Holyfield 

TE / FB-

Olsen / Thomas / Manhertz / Armah

WR-

Moore / Samuel / Wright / Hogan / Smith / Robinson

OL-

Little / Williams / Paradis / Turner / Moton / GVR / Larsen / Hearn / Daley

Offense Total- 24

----------------------------------------

LB - Kuechly / Thompson / Carter Jr / Smith / Norris

Edge - Addison / Irvin / Burns / Miller / Obada / Haynes

DL - Short / GMC / Poe / Love / Butler

CB - Bradberry / Jackson / Cockrell / Seymour / Elliot

S - Reid / Gaulden / Jones / FA

Defense Total - 26

--------------------------------------

LS - Jansen

K- Gano

P - Palardy

Special Teams Total - 3

[panthers55]

You are right it is way too early. Let's see how the QBs do before assuming we keep 2 QBs and Grier is the guy. Let's see how Newton does to see if he is 100%. Lots of good battles which will decide how our roster gets built this year.

[TheCasillas]

I dont think we go into the season with 6 WR. If we go with 6, I think godwin over robinson. Sounds like Godwin is not going to be an easy PS stash.

[bababoey]

I don't think we will see 11 DL/Edge players.  10 maybe but if we carry 11 that means we are going to be thin at other areas.  And being thin at QB (in your example) after the last 2 years we have seen from Cam's shoulder, might not be a good idea.

[MHS831]

11 minutes ago, TheCasillas said:

I dont think we go into the season with 6 WR. If we go with 6, I think godwin over robinson. Sounds like Godwin is not going to be an easy PS stash.

I agree--and if Smith does not have a good camp....

I think, with Cam's shoulder having not played a whole season, we have to keep 3 QBs. 

Not sure how Obada fits---

 

 

[SetfreexX]

Pretty sure Heinecke and Allen qualify for the PS, if we get to the 3rd QB depth isn't really going to matter. 

I think we carry 6 receivers due to not having a returner come in to replace Byrd. Robinson is more proven as a receiver over Ross, and Godwin as a 7th rounder isn't guaranteed anything. 

[Squirrel]

Sheesh wrs look like crap. 

[panthers55]

2 hours ago, SetfreexX said:

Pretty sure Heinecke and Allen qualify for the PS, if we get to the 3rd QB depth isn't really going to matter. 

I think we carry 6 receivers due to not having a returner come in to replace Byrd. Robinson is more proven as a receiver over Ross, and Godwin as a 7th rounder isn't guaranteed anything. 

Not sure either of them will be worse than Grier. I think one of these two will be the backup. Grier will be the third stronger unless he really improves and the other of these two will be eligible for the PS. I would like to think Grier can be the backup but from what I have heard, he is not ready yet.

[shaqattaq]

On 7/22/2019 at 1:07 PM, panthers55 said:

You are right it is way too early. Let's see how the QBs do before assuming we keep 2 QBs and Grier is the guy. Let's see how Newton does to see if he is 100%. Lots of good battles which will decide how our roster gets built this year.

I also think we keep 3 QB's. I like the little we saw from Allen, but I assume that the coaches weren't overly impressed or they wouldn't have gotton so hot and bothered by Grier. I predict (without a snap being taken in training camp) Heinicke getting the QB3 spot as more of a teacher role for Greir. He has 3 years with Norv.

[panthers55]

3 hours ago, shaqattaq said:

I also think we keep 3 QB's. I like the little we saw from Allen, but I assume that the coaches weren't overly impressed or they wouldn't have gotton so hot and bothered by Grier. I predict (without a snap being taken in training camp) Heinicke getting the QB3 spot as more of a teacher role for Greir. He has 3 years with Norv.

Allen seems to play well but he is so small I doubt he can stay healthy. Heinicke has the size to play but didnt seem to click like Allen did. Both weren't ideal which is why we drafted Grier. Hopefully Cam is 100% and backup isn't a critical.position this season.

[mc52beast]

Agree with most of the list but;

i don’t think Butler sticks around another season

Not sold on Grier being the day one b/u

Dont know if Obada makes it, had one good game and disappeared

[XOBlackxJokerOX]

I made a few changes but all in all, I like the list.

QB-

Newton / Grier / Allen

HB- 

CMC / Scarlett / Holyfield 

TE / FB-

Olsen / Thomas / Wolff / Armah

WR-

Moore / Samuel / Wright / Hogan / Smith / Robinson

OL-

Little / Williams / Paradis / Turner / Moton / GVR / Larsen / Hearn /

Offense Total- 24

----------------------------------------

LB - Kuechly / Thompson / Carter Jr / Smith / Norris / FA

Edge - Addison / Irvin / Burns / Miller / Obada / Haynes

DL - Short / GMC / Poe / Love /

CB - Bradberry / Jackson / Cockrell / Seymour / Elliot / FA

S - Reid / Gaulden / Jones / FA

Defense Total - 26

--------------------------------------

LS - Jansen

K- Gano

P - Palardy

Special Teams Total - 3

[Xtreme]

I don't see us hanging onto Butler & I don't think we roll with six receivers, but it wouldn't surprise me if we did. 

Secondary scares the piss outta me, especially safety. Reid is the only good one. Gaulden has potential, but still needs work and Jones doesn't deserve a roster spot IMO. He's a below average safety and I never understood why we keep players solely for special teams. Most kickoffs result in touchbacks and most punts result in fair catches. I just don't see why he's needed. Get someone who can play both. 

[Bronn]

QB: Cam, Grier, Allen
RB: CMC, Scarlett, Holyfield
FB: Armah
WR: Moore, Samuel, Wright, Smith, Hogan, Godwin
TE: Olsen, Thomas, Manhertz
T: Moton, Little, Williams, Daley
G: Turner, Van Roten, Greene
C: Paradis, Larsen

DL1:Poe, Love
DL3:McCoy, Short
DL5: Addison, Cox, Obada
EDGE: Burns, Irvin, Haynes, Miller
LB: Kuechly, Thompson, Norris, Carter, Smith
CB: Bradberry, Cockrell, Jackson, Elder, Seymour
FS: Gaulden, Jones, Luke
SS: Reid

LS: Jansen
K: Gano
P: Palardy

I could see us trading for a safety like Josh Jones or picking up someone who is cut at a number of positions.

I think we carry 6 WRs. If we're happy with what Cam's showing, we'll only roll with two QBs IMHO. I have three on here just in case.