Coleman wants to come back

[Jmac]

According to what I have read, he wants to come back here..."dream come true" according to a quote. I say don't look back...been there and done that. Is he worth another shot?

[t96]

Vet min depth flyer who isn’t guaranteed a spot on the 53, then yeah. 

[Daddy_Uncle]

Yeah that would be a bad move. He was great for us for one season but he has nothing to offer now. Gauldon has more value

[trucpfan]

Just now, t96 said:

Vet min depth flyer who isn’t guaranteed a spot on the 53, then yeah. 

I agree completely but Ron loves vets after assessing the roster honestly Coleman would probably best the youngsters out based off knowledge and experience. But let’s pass rather see Tre much younger faster etc.. his pff ratings were ashtray so it’s hard seeing us bring back an underperforming aging Safety.

[KillerKat]

Coleman is trash at this point

[TheSpecialJuan]

7 minutes ago, Jmac said:

According to what I have read, he wants to come back here..."dream come true" according to a quote. I say don't look back...been there and done that. Is he worth another shot?

WHO? 

[therealmjl]

Where you read that at

[panthers55]

For me it is what kind of scheme are we running and how does he match up in that scheme. Guys who one year are great and then fall apart quickly aren't getting old and slow usually.  Most times their skill set isn't suited to how they are being used. Sure a simple concept but it is how additions or subtractions should be judged. It doesn't matter what McCoy did in Tampa, it is about how productive he will be in our setup and how much it will cost to secure his services.  Cost versus benefit..   As a fan I want all the good players. Screw sharing.....

[PurityControl]

[TheSpecialJuan]

13 minutes ago, KillerKat said:

Coleman is trash at this point

That is not very nice, sir

[KillerKat]

1 minute ago, TheSpecialJuan said:

That is not very nice, sir

He has one good year because Norman shut down half the field, then has sucked ever since. Don't care if it's not nice.

[Toomers]

  Please no. Even at vet minimum. He is not close to the type of FS we need. Cutting him was one of Hurneys best moves. Replacing him with similar players was not. 

 I would seriously rather sign Mike Mitchell. He looked good last year in his time with Indy. And still has the athleticism to cover some ground. 

[t96]

28 minutes ago, KillerKat said:

He has one good year because Norman shut down half the field, then has sucked ever since. Don't care if it's not nice.

He was still solid in ‘16. Terrible in ‘17 though 

[Jesse]

I’d like to be signed by the Panthers too, but that’s not happening.