Gettleman is getting absolutely destroyed by national media... STILL

[pantherclaw]

Not a single person on this huddle disliked gettleman until Steve Smith was cut. Nowadays you guys are so obsessed with hating the man but you guys are still hating on him when it's all water under the bridge.

[Go DJ that's my DJ]

9 hours ago, Cracka McNasty said:

It's been 3 days since the draft. 

We have no idea if literally anyone is any good yet. 

Let's evaluate again in 3 years. 

lets talk about dave's 2016 draft then. Id say it was the worst in panther history

[Smithers]

Gettleman set us back 2 years at least with his stupidity.  Cutting Smitty and Norman. Signing Matt Kalil to a massive deal.  Drafting some terrible players (Benjamin, Funchess, Hall, Ealy, etc).  His ego makes him an ineffective GM.  The 15-1 season was mostly a Hurney drafted/signed team.  

Screw G-man...I hope he’s fired in NY as well. 

[Mr. Scot]

12 minutes ago, Smithers said:

Gettleman set us back 2 years at least with his stupidity.  Cutting Smitty and Norman. Signing Matt Kalil to a massive deal.  Drafting some terrible players (Benjamin, Funchess, Hall, Ealy, etc).  His ego makes him an ineffective GM.  The 15-1 season was mostly a Hurney drafted/signed team.  

Screw G-man...I hope he’s fired in NY as well. 

Team was in the Super Bowl one year after Smith was cut...

In the playoffs again with a Gettleman roster the year after Norman was cut...

First year Marty Hurney has full control, team has historic meltdown...

"Gettleman set us back two years"

[Tbe]

1 hour ago, Smithers said:

Gettleman set us back 2 years at least with his stupidity.  Cutting Smitty and Norman. Signing Matt Kalil to a massive deal.  Drafting some terrible players (Benjamin, Funchess, Hall, Ealy, etc).  His ego makes him an ineffective GM.  The 15-1 season was mostly a Hurney drafted/signed team.  

Screw G-man...I hope he’s fired in NY as well. 

To be 100% fair, that D line was mostly Gettleman. So was taking a chance on Orr. The secondary was largely Gettleman signings as well (I think) . He did ok in free agency, not so great in the draft.

The main players that year were Hurney drafted guys, but they were high draft picks Hurney got as a consolation prize for constantly putting together terrible teams.

[TheSpecialJuan]

10 hours ago, The Huddler said:

btw, media reaction and fuxking wingo of all people isnt a barometer of future success

 

 

anyway, gettleman has balls to carry out his plan.. something he wasnt able to do here. 

 

my prediction is they will be a force very soon 

agree

[Smithers]

3 hours ago, Mr. Scot said:

Team was in the Super Bowl one year after Smith was cut...

In the playoffs again with a Gettleman roster the year after Norman was cut...

First year Marty Hurney has full control, team has historic meltdown...

"Gettleman set us back two years"

A Gettleman roster???  Please list the number of major impact players from that team that Gettleman drafted. lol

[Smithers]

2 hours ago, Tbe said:

To be 100% fair, that D line was mostly Gettleman. So was taking a chance on Orr. The secondary was largely Gettleman signings as well (I think) . He did ok in free agency, not so great in the draft.

The main players that year were Hurney drafted guys, but they were high draft picks Hurney got as a consolation prize for constantly putting together terrible teams.

To be fair..Gettleman flopped on high draft picks such as Benjamin and Funchess.  Hurney nailed one of our best our best players ever, Smitty, in the 3rd.

[Basbear]

those 3 first were awful, AWFUL.

The rest looked very good.

[Mr. Scot]

10 minutes ago, Smithers said:

A Gettleman roster???  Please list the number of major impact players from that team that Gettleman drafted. lol

Well let's see... In that years draft alone, Taylor Moton, Curtis Samuel, Alex Armah... oh, and some kid named McCaffrey who, I've heard, is kind of a big deal in our offense. They played alongside guys like Trai Turner, Kawann Short, Shaq Thompson and James Bradberry from prior drafts among others. Even more guys to note if you throw in free agents or undrafted players like Andrew Norwell.

Now I'm sure you'll throw some dumbass spin in like "oh, I don't consider any of those guys impact players" or some such, but the reality is we were five years removed from Marty Hurney at that time. While he still had players on the roster - and important ones - that was Gettleman's team, as was the Super Bowl team in 2015.

But hey, don't let stuff like that get in the way.

[Smithers]

17 minutes ago, Mr. Scot said:

Well let's see... In that years draft alone, Taylor Moton, Curtis Samuel, Alex Armah... oh, and some kid named McCaffrey who, I've heard, is kind of a big deal in our offense. They played alongside guys like Trai Turner, Kawann Short, Shaq Thompson and James Bradberry from prior drafts among others. Even more guys to note if you throw in free agents or undrafted players like Andrew Norwell.

Now I'm sure you'll throw some dumbass spin in like "oh, I don't consider any of those guys impact players" or some such, but the reality is we were five years removed from Marty Hurney at that time. While he still had players on the roster - and important ones - that was Gettleman's team, as was the Super Bowl team in 2015.

But hey, don't let stuff like that get in the way.

Alex Armah?  Really?  And everyone on this board complains about Short, Thompson, and Bradberry. 

Hurney drafted Cam, Luke, Davis, and Ryan Kalil.  And don’t play the whole “he had high picks” card.  Because the only true franchise player you listed (CMC) for G-Man was a high pick.  Hurney also has Norman and Smitty in later rounds.  Gman has Benjamin and Funchess as early flops.  

[Zithers]

I'd love to have Gettleman back. Marty Hurney sucks ass.

[Cpt slay a ho]

1 hour ago, Smithers said:

To be fair..Gettleman flopped on high draft picks such as Benjamin and Funchess.  Hurney nailed one of our best our best players ever, Smitty, in the 3rd.

If I’m correct hurney didn’t draft Smith 

[carpanfan96]

23 minutes ago, Cpt slay a ho said:

If I’m correct hurney didn’t draft Smith 

He wasn't the GM, but according to various reports he ran the draft that year along with Seifert and the head of scouting that year. Assisted with the board, scouting and other things with the draft. One of the reasons they were comfortable making him the GM after that dreadful 2001 seasons.