Jump to content

  • Welcome!

    Register and log in easily with Twitter or Google accounts!

    Or simply create a new Huddle account. 

    Members receive fewer ads , access our dark theme, and the ability to join the discussion!

     

Walterfootball Position reviews

micnificent28

By micnificent28,
in Carolina Panthers

Recommended Posts

micnificent28 Mentor

micnificent28

Posted
Posted

http://walterfootball.com/draft2019positionreviewDE.php

I know how we all feel about walterfootball and his analysis is sketchy at best. But he has a feature that I haven't seen any other draft source have and its great for perspective. I know this is all subjective,but I love his position review something he does yearly where he combine this years class and the one before it to show how prospects would rank and the class as a whole if the two merged.

Defensive End Class
Early-round talent: B-
Mid-round: B-
Late-round: C
Overall grade: C+

2019 prospects vs 2018 
Bradley Chubb 
Nick Bosa 
Montez Sweat 
Rashan Gary 
Clelin Ferrell 
Marcus Davenport 
Brian Burns 
Zach Allen 
Breeland Speaks 
Kemoko Turay 
Tyquan Lewis 
Jaylon Ferguson 
Chad Thomas 
Sam Hubbard 
Jachai Polite 
Rasheem Green 

The 2018 NFL Draft was weak at defensive end, and comparing this year's edge rushers to last year's class makes that all the more glaring. If you were to merge the two classes together, Nick Bosa and Bradley Chubb are equal as prospects. Montez Sweat, Rashan Gary and Clelin Ferrell are better prospects than Marcus Davenport, but Davenport is better than Brian Burns and Zach Allen. Burns and Allen are better than 2018 second-round pick Breeland Speaks. Jaylon Ferguson would go behind Tyquan Lewis at the end of the second round and ahead of Chad Thomas in Round 3. Jachai Polite is only toward the end of this group because of off-the-field issues. If Polite were clean off the field, he would be between Bosa and Sweat. 


He proceeds to place projections on who he thinks is the safest pick at the position followed by how he has done the last 5-6 year in projecting those safe picks.

Safest Pick: Nick Bosa, Ohio State
Previous Picks:
2018: Bradley Chubb
2017: Myles Garrett
2016: DeForest Buckner
2015: Dante Fowler
2014: Jadeveon Clowney
2013: Bjoern Werner 

Looking back at the previous picks, I'm pretty strong. Chubb got off to an excellent start with a strong rookie year. Garrett is on his way to being one of the best defensive players in the NFL, and Buckner was phenomenal in 2018. Buckner is one of the best young defensive linemen in the NFL. An injury robbed Fowler of his rookie season, but he started to emerge as a dangerous edge defender in his third year. He has upside to be even better over the next year or two. Clowney is a Pro Bowler who was dominant in 2016 and 2017. He has become one of the top defensive players in the NFL. Werner was drafted into a 3-4, and that was a terrible fit for him as he was a 4-3 defensive end. He was a huge bust, so I was way off on him, but the most of the others are panning out very well, with Fowler being okay but not good. 

This was an easy choice because Bosa is a safe prospect to develop into a good NFL pro. For the next level, Bosa looks like a potential franchise edge rusher capable of producing double-digit sack seasons on an annual basis. He could be a player who goes to multiple Pro Bowls and is one of the most dangerous pass-rushers in the NFL. Bosa is worthy of being a high first-round pick in any draft class. Team sources also feel that he is a safe pick. 

 

He then goes on to Project who he thinks is the biggest bust potential similar to above. after that it get interesting... He breaks the top players in this class at there position and rank them by individual attributes or where they win.

Defensive End Rankings by Attributes


Pass Rush:
NFL prototype: J.J. Watt, Texans

  1. Nick Bosa
  2. Montez Sweat
  3. Jachai Polite
  4. Brian Burns
  5. Clelin Ferrell
  6. Rashan Gary
  7. Jaylon Ferguson
  8. Zach Allen


Run Defense:
NFL prototype: Jadeveon Clowney, Texans

  1. Zach Allen
  2. Rashan Gary
  3. Clelin Ferrell
  4. Nick Bosa
  5. Jaylon Ferguson
  6. Montez Sweat
  7. Brian Burns
  8. Jachai Polite

There is more to read here but I just thought I would share the basic features of one of my favorite reads.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Adb6368 Proficient

Adb6368

Posted
Posted
46 minutes ago, micnificent28 said:

 

Safest Pick: Nick Bosa, Ohio State
Previous Picks:
2018: Bradley Chubb
2017: Myles Garrett
2016: DeForest Buckner
2015: Dante Fowler
2014: Jadeveon Clowney
2013: Bjoern Werner 
 

Is it bad when half of your safest picks are busts?

Link to comment
Share on other sites
micnificent28 Mentor

micnificent28

Posted
  • Author
Posted
5 minutes ago, LinvilleGorge said:

C+ grade for this year's DE class?

L-O-fuging-L! This is why no one takes him seriously.

Not so much... this might be the best defensive line class in history, but edge is a separate debate. As far as defensive ends go after Ferrell your just throwing darts at the wall. Norris. Plenty other think this edge class is not so deep.

61F7DDD8-FE67-4BD7-9D48-61E84447E90C.png

EBF81987-A474-4B72-BBE8-4C8212AAD216.png

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Palmetto Newbie

Palmetto

Posted
Posted
6 minutes ago, Adb6368 said:

Is it bad when half of your safest picks are busts?

Its a shame that anyone that watched College FB knew Bjoern Werner  was not that good and was going to be a bust but most of the draft analyst tried to push this guy as a top pass rusher

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Toomers Mentor

Toomers

Posted
Posted
15 minutes ago, micnificent28 said:

I would say the only bust there is Warner..

I would think that JAX had more in mind for Fowler than one good year and a 3rd round pick when he went 3rd overall.. 

 But Buckner isn’t one. Not close. 

The others are two “freak” #1 overalls and and #5 who might be better than both. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites
micnificent28 Mentor

micnificent28

Posted
  • Author
Posted
12 minutes ago, Toomers said:

I would think that JAX had more in mind for Fowler than one good year and a 3rd round pick when he went 3rd overall.. 

 But Buckner isn’t one. Not close. 

The others are two “freak” #1 overalls and and #5 who might be better than both. 

I agree you had more in mind when you drafted Fowler,But he also had one season wiped away due to injuries, they also gave up on him before the end of his rookie contract. so basically you had 2-3 season to actually see him and one of those seasons he had 8 sacks. I think he has shown he can be an effective pass rusher,but so far he is just ok.... Not a bust but not a splash he is a NFL caliber player tho. A bust in my mind is a guy who just isnt an effective football player and washes out the league.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Toomers Mentor

Toomers

Posted
Posted
Just now, micnificent28 said:

I agree you had more in mind when you drafted Fowler,But he also had one season wiped away due to injuries, they also gave up on him before the end of his rookie contract. so basically you had 2-3 season to actually see him and one of those seasons he had 8 sacks. I think he has shown he can be an effective pass rusher,but so far he is just ok.... Not a bust but not a splash he is a NFL caliber player tho. A bust in my mind is a guy who just isnt an effective football player and washes out the league.

  Remember in the context of 3rd overall.

 That’s a similar resume to KB with injury and play and even return. You could argue we got a lot more from KB. At 28. And he’s a bust. 

  Doesn’t matter what he does to JAX after trade. He’s value is done with the trade. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites
LinvilleGorge Grand Master

LinvilleGorge

Posted
Posted
5 minutes ago, micnificent28 said:

I agree you had more in mind when you drafted Fowler,But he also had one season wiped away due to injuries, they also gave up on him before the end of his rookie contract. so basically you had 2-3 season to actually see him and one of those seasons he had 8 sacks. I think he has shown he can be an effective pass rusher,but so far he is just ok.... Not a bust but not a splash he is a NFL caliber player tho. A bust in my mind is a guy who just isnt an effective football player and washes out the league.

You don't give up on the #3 overall pick in the draft during his rookie contract unless you're really damn sure he's a bust.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
micnificent28 Mentor

micnificent28

Posted
  • Author
Posted
3 minutes ago, Toomers said:

  Really not relevant to the team that drafted him. For which he was a disappointment. 

If you lose one year due to injuries, then one year you have 8 sacks. then hes gone by year 4, I don't think you did enough research to say he's a bust. especially if he is effective elsewhere on another team. I think Butler has shown to be a bust more so than Fowler did but the Panthers are still sitting on him and not throwing in the towel.

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Go to topic listing

  • PMH4OWPW7JD2TDGWZKTOYL2T3E.jpg

  • Topics

  • Posts

    • mav1234
      Passing yards per game leaders

      By mav1234 · Posted

      I mean it's not even like this was his worst game of the season... I'm not done with him by any means but this feels more the norm for him than the exception:/
    • mav1234
      BREAKING: Panthers Announce Four Moves Including LB Trevin Wallace To IR

      By mav1234 · Posted

      I'd give it a C mainly because of Brooks.  If we just didn't have a 2nd I'd argue B to B+ tbh. Brooks was a bad gamble, tho one that could still pay off long term. Yes XL only has 400 yards but... Look who is throwing him the ball. And I think he isn't a "true #1" but he's been able to consistently get open. Hands definitely need to be cleaned up.  But he should end the year with 500-600 yards. Like you said - Sanders looks great.  Get him a better QB / more time with a QB and I think he's gonna impress. We added a couple rotational players on D that have both made plays and show promise for the future from later rounds. So I'd say, Brooks really hurts this drafts grade. It'll be interesting to see how it progresses over the next 3 years. I've overall really liked Morgan's FA acquisitions, so...
    • Gapanthersfan
      Would you trade Ickey

      By Gapanthersfan · Posted

      Oh he would absolutely flourish. It’s the panthers way. It’s no different with coaches. Sometimes they reach their expiration date, go somewhere else, and find new success.  Similarly to Burns, how long to wait for the light to finally turn on?  Market forces will demand a salary that the panthers can not responsibly match. Sliding him to guard will fit his skill set better, but he has played LT for 3 years. He will receive offers from other teams wanting to pay him LT money.  At guard, he won’t start with what they have paid Hunt and Lewis. Center then?? Dunno. Maybe? He will become a backup by default once they draft their stud LT. I doubt Dan just stands pat. That’s not his MO.  So where does this put him? Can you match what other teams will offer for a backup LT/guard? Do you dish out franchise LT $ on a guy who still needs significant improvement in pass protection. This team will be DOA in the playoffs with the very first team who has a formidable speed rusher. What if he has hit his ceiling in pass protection already and they sign him long term? It’s a big gamble either way. 
×
×
  • Create New...