Have we all seen WR D.K Metcalf?

[LinvilleGorge]

1 minute ago, ncfan said:

Im not doubting you buuut watched him for years?

Take the rivalry glasses off for a second 

 

His Freshman year: 2catches for 2 TDs, then missed the rest of the season with a foot injury

Year 2 coming off a foot injury, he had 646 yards sharing balls with AJ Brown.

Then this past year, had 569 in just 7 games before going down with a neck injury.

 

He never even played 2 full seasons at Ole Miss.

 

So is Jeffrey Simmons overrated?  7 sacks in 3 seasons?

All of a sudden a guy missing lots of games to injury is being spun into a positive. I get it, the guy looks like a Greek god and he tests like a track and field Olympian. But he's raw as hell and sure seems injury prone.

[bobcat91]

2 minutes ago, ncfan said:

Im not doubting you buuut watched him for years?

Take the rivalry glasses off for a second 

 

His Freshman year: 2catches for 2 TDs, then missed the rest of the season with a foot injury

Year 2 coming off a foot injury, he had 646 yards sharing balls with AJ Brown.

Then this past year, had 569 in just 7 games before going down with a neck injury.

 

He never even played 2 full seasons at Ole Miss.

 

So is Jeffrey Simmons overrated?  7 sacks in 3 seasons?

I listed his stats for his career. Does that say top 10 pick?  Simmons is double teamed every play. His stats dont lie

[ncfan]

Just now, LinvilleGorge said:

All of a sudden a guy missing lots of games to injury is being spun into a positive. I get it, the guy looks like a Greek god and he tests like a track and field Olympian. But he's raw as hell and sure seems injury prone.

Im not saying he's not, he's raw as he11.  Thus the reason ive been comparing him to Damaryius Thomas the whole time vs the Julio Megatron comparisons.

 

But GMs will see all that talent and drool and want to grab him

[LinvilleGorge]

2 minutes ago, Mr. Scot said:

I agree.

Someone's going to pick him thinking they're getting the next Calvin Johnson. I'm not sure what they're actually going to get, but I don't think it's going to be the next Calvin Johnson.

Honestly, I'd expect Cordarrelle Patterson and if I got more I'd be thrilled, but if you draft this guy thinking you're getting Megatron or Julio Jones right out of the gates I think you're gonna be really, really disappointed.

[bobcat91]

4 minutes ago, ncfan said:

Im not doubting you buuut watched him for years?

Take the rivalry glasses off for a second 

 

His Freshman year: 2catches for 2 TDs, then missed the rest of the season with a foot injury

Year 2 coming off a foot injury, he had 646 yards sharing balls with AJ Brown.

Then this past year, had 569 in just 7 games before going down with a neck injury.

 

He never even played 2 full seasons at Ole Miss.

 

So is Jeffrey Simmons overrated?  7 sacks in 3 seasons?

Also, I am lauding A J Brown from Ole Miss who is going to be all pro. I think he is that good. Larry Fitzgerald good

[ncfan]

1 minute ago, bobcat91 said:

I listed his stats for his career. Does that say top 10 pick?  Simmons is double teamed every play. His stats dont lie

You his stats for his career is a reason why then ignore he's only played 1 full season there

Then use a excuse for Simmons

[LinvilleGorge]

1 minute ago, ncfan said:

Im not saying he's not, he's raw as he11.  Thus the reason ive been comparing him to Damaryius Thomas the whole time vs the Julio Megatron comparisons.

 

But GMs will see all that talent and drool and want to grab him

And just think about this, Thomas had nearly double the college production of Metcalf while playing in a triple option offense.

[ncfan]

Just now, bobcat91 said:

Also, I am lauding A J Brown from Ole Miss who is going to be all pro. I think he is that good. Larry Fitzgerald good

See I think Brown is more product of the system, a little slow.  I just cant shake a Treadwell comparison

[LinvilleGorge]

1 minute ago, bobcat91 said:

Also, I am lauding A J Brown from Ole Miss who is going to be all pro. I think he is that good. Larry Fitzgerald good

I don't know about Fitz good. I mean, you can make a legit argument that Fitz is the 2nd best WR ever.

[LinvilleGorge]

1 minute ago, ncfan said:

See I think Brown is more product of the system, a little slow.  I just cant shake a Treadwell comparison

How can Brown be the product of a system while a far superior athlete is supposedly this elite NFL WR prospect while doing far less in that same WR friendly offense?

[bobcat91]

1 minute ago, ncfan said:

You his stats for his career is a reason why then ignore he's only played 1 full season there

Then use a excuse for Simmons

No excuse on Simmons. Hes a DT that was near the top of the SEC for tackles behind the line of scrimmage. Again, AJ is the better player. If you want to ride the DK train, be my guest. He will be a bust

[Shocker]

1 minute ago, ncfan said:

See I think Brown is more product of the system, a little slow.  I just cant shake a Treadwell comparison

4.49 isn’t that bad and AJ Brown is really good...Treadwell is really slow 4.64.  

[ncfan]

1 minute ago, LinvilleGorge said:

And just think about this, Thomas had nearly double the college production of Metcalf while playing in a triple option offense.

Thomas also played how many more games.

Metcalf didnt even play 2 season

 

Thomas played 39 games, and was their only guy really being targeted 

Metcalf play 21 sharing the ball with several other guys

[micnificent28]

12 minutes ago, ncfan said:

Im not doubting you buuut watched him for years?

Take the rivalry glasses off for a second 

 

His Freshman year: 2catches for 2 TDs, then missed the rest of the season with a foot injury

Year 2 coming off a foot injury, he had 646 yards sharing balls with AJ Brown.

Then this past year, had 569 in just 7 games before going down with a neck injury.

 

He never even played 2 full seasons at Ole Miss.

 

So is Jeffrey Simmons overrated?  7 sacks in 3 seasons?

This is kind of my point.. how much did you really get to see of D.K if he was barely on the field...