OBJ to the Texans?

[Mr. Scot]

1 hour ago, Icege said:

I broke down the two's draft histories in 2017 when Hurney came back on board and also included the Steelers as a point of reference since we want to mimic them as a franchise as well as place precedent on drafting and developing talent rather than signing free agents.

The numbers were clear that Gettleman was also the superior drafter. If you're interested in the breakdown, I can do some digging.

Unfortunately for Gettleman, another requirement for being good at anything you do is being able to do it without being an abrasive ***** (unless you're promoting a fight or running for president apparently) which he just couldn't do.

It's not as well remembered, but that was a source of friction between Richardson and Bill Polian too.

Guess you could say Richardson didn't work well with yankees.

[X-Clown]

2 hours ago, Unbreakable Split Glass said:

They were good

They were on great contracts, well worth top 5 money at each of their positions

[Unbreakable Split Glass]

1 hour ago, X-Clown said:

They were on great contracts, well worth top 5 money at each of their positions

Yeah check out KK, Kalil, Greg and TD

[Toomers]

18 minutes ago, Unbreakable Split Glass said:

Yeah check out KK, Kalil, Greg and TD

Do you mean the “ Greg and TD” that DG was fired for not giving extensions? Is that the two you speak of? 

  This version of you isn’t very good at this. 

[Mother Grabber]

13 hours ago, Mr. Scot said:

I hadn't heard anything about that 

certainly not in this thread. it should be renamed to “In case you didn’t see the other 100 threads on this topic, here’s another thread about Dave vs Marty, which offers no new insights”

[Unbreakable Split Glass]

6 hours ago, Toomers said:

Do you mean the “ Greg and TD” that DG was fired for not giving extensions? Is that the two you speak of? 

  This version of you isn’t very good at this. 

Yeah i agree

[KaseKlosed]

On 2/21/2019 at 12:09 PM, Icege said:

Not including the 2017 season since that was Gettleman + Hurney.

Gettleman:
40W 23L 1T (.625)
x1 NFC Championship
x3 NFC South titles
x4 playoff appearances
x4 seasons (2013, 2014, 2015, 2016)

Hurney:
93W 99L (.484)
x1 NFC Championship
x2 NFC South titles
x3 playoff appearances
x12 seasons as Panthers' GM (2002, 2003, 2004, 2005, 2006, 2007, 2008, 2009, 2010, 2011, 2012, 2018)

If we look include Hurney's time as Director of Player Operations in 1998, then the record is 97W 111L (.466). Can we please stop this ridiculous narrative that he is/was a better GM?

Lmaoooo DG did this with Hurneys main draft picks leading our team. DG draft history and player relationship is trash. 

[Icege]

31 minutes ago, KaseKlosed said:

Lmaoooo DG did this with Hurneys main draft picks leading our team. DG draft history and player relationship is trash. 

Copypasting my response to this nonsense last year

 

15-1 Roster:
QB: Cam (Hurney), Anderson (Hurney), Webb (Gettleman)
RB: JStew (Hurney), Tolbert (Hurney), Fozzy (Gettleman), Wegher (Gettleman), CAP (Gettleman)
WR: Funchess (Gettleman), Cotchery (Gettleman), Ginn (Gettleman), Philly (Gettleman), Bersin (Hurney), Norwood (Gettleman)
TE: Olsen (Hurney), Dickson (Gettleman), Simonson (Gettleman)
OT: Oher (Gettleman), Remmers (Gettleman), Williams (Gettleman)
G/C: Kalil (Hurney), Norwell (Gettleman), Turner (Gettleman), Scott (Gettleman), Velasco (Gettleman)
ST: Gano (Gettleman), Nortman (Hurney), Jansen (Hurney)
DE: Johnson (Hurney), Allen (Gettleman), Ealy (Gettleman), Addison (Beane), Delaire (Gettleman)
DT: Lotulelei (Gettleman), Short (Gettleman), Love (Gettleman), Edwards (Hurney)
LB: Kuechly (Hurney), Davis (Hurney), Thompson (Gettleman), Klein (Gettleman), Mayo (Gettleman), Jacobs (Gettleman)
CB: Norman (Hurney), McClain (Hurney), Williams (Gettleman), Young (Gettleman), Finnegan (Gettleman)
S: Coleman (Gettleman), Harper (Gettleman), Boston (Gettleman), Jones (Hurney), Marlowe (Gettleman)

IR: DE Alexander (Hurney), WR Benjamin (Gettleman), OT Chandler (Hurney), OG Green (Gettleman), WR Hill (Gettleman), CB Tillman (Gettleman), DE Miley (Gettleman), OG Silatolu (Hurney), CB Benwikere (Gettleman)

PS: Alexcih, Askew, Ball, Blechen, Byrd, Cox, Dismukes, Dowling, Foucault, Horton (all Gettleman)

Not including IR/PS...
Gettleman players: 36
Hurney players: 16

Including 22, 21, 11 formations...
Offensive starters (Hurney): 5 (Cam, JStew, Olsen, Kalil, Toldozer)
Offensive starters (Gettleman): 8 (Cotchery, Ginn, Oher, Remmers, Norwell, Turner, Dickson, Funchess)

Including 4-3 & Nickel
Defensive starters (Hurney): 4 (Kuechly, Davis, Johnson, Norman)
Defensive starters (Gettleman): 8 (Lotulelei, Short, Allen, Tillman, Coleman, Harper, Finnegan, Thompson)

 

[Mother Grabber]

aaannnd, boom goes the dynamite