Is Edelman a HOFer?

[mc52beast]

For some reason people in the media are declaring that after Edelman’s MVP performance on Sunday he should be inducted into the HOF.

Dude is a clutch receiver and shows up in the post season but his career numbers don’t say HOF. I think it’s a freaking joke people actually believe he’s worthy.https://www.12up.com/posts/6289173-this-stat-proves-julian-edelman-s-hall-of-fame-case-is-an-absolute-joke

[Dex]

Not yet. He's an amazing player with a great story though. He simply doesn't have the individual stats yet.

[Carolina Cajun]

What a scrappy high moter/high IQ gym rat!

[Jeremy Igo]

El Oh No

[joemac]

Brandon Lafell has more career receiving yards than Julian Edelman.  So in a word.....No.

[OriginalPantherDan]

Hell no, not at this point in his career. Sure, he’s had some nice games, but he’s not alone in that category. Want to know who has more career receiving yards than Edelman? Brandon LaFell. ‘Nuff said. 

[Malt Liquor]

News flash. Who gives a s h i t? It's not Panther related.

[joemac]

3 minutes ago, Malt Liquor said:

News flash. Who gives a s h i t? It's not Panther related.

Off-season mode, homie.

[JARROD]

Bawahahahahahhahahah

[t96]

9 minutes ago, Jeremy Igo said:

El Oh No

The fact that this thought has ever run through anyone's mind is completely ridiculous.

Let's compare to Hines Ward who probably won't get in himself...

 

Hines Ward: 1,088 catches, 13,624 yards, 95 TDs, 1 SB MVP on a run first team

Edelman: 614 catches, 6,802 yards, 35 TDs and 1 SB MVP with GOAT coach in a pass friendly system

[Panthercougar68]

If he were on any other team this wouldn’t be a discussion. He benefits from being in a Bill and Brady system which probably contributes to more than half of his success.

There are not many players that leave the NE system and thrive other places.

[t96]

10 minutes ago, OriginalPantherDan said:

Hell no, not at this point in his career. Sure, he’s had some nice games, but he’s not alone in that category. Want to know who has more career receiving yards than Edelman? Brandon LaFell. ‘Nuff said. 

McCaffeey could have more yards from scrimmage after next season than Edelman has in over 10 years...

[Ricky Spanish]

0 pro bowls

0 all pros

Nah.

[LinvilleGorge]

Not even close. Great player for sure, but nowhere in the discussion for the HOF. With the NFL going more and more pass heavy it's going to take ridiculous numbers to even get in the conversation as a WR moving forward. I don't think Smitty has more than a 50/50 shot and Edelman is nowhere close to Smitty.