Argue Hurney’s case

[Cpt slay a ho]

12 minutes ago, Harbingers said:

Getts wasn’t bad. And he took us out of cap hell, that Hurney put us in. Anyone that thinks he was a bad GM is laughable.

Both sucked 

[Toomers]

1 minute ago, Cpt slay a ho said:

Both sucked 

  But one had an 80% success rate of making the playoffs with Rivera. The other is still holding a donut in that category. So by YOUR criteria, one was much better than the other. 

[ncfan]

4 minutes ago, thebigcat said:

I thought he nailed this year's draft with:

DJ

Donte

Ian

That's three starters and got a ST player out of it in Carter

He nailed a 1st round pick that he really didnt even really make the pick.  It was said new OC Norv and Cam practically begged for Moore who was the top WR in the draft.

He fell in our lap. When others thought he'd go earlier.

Thomas and Jackson was a good pick.

While the 3rd round pick was a total flop.

[Smithers]

One of the best draft classes this team has seen in a long time.  Moore, Thomas, and Jackson look legit.  Anything else will be a bonus.

[ncfan]

3 minutes ago, Toomers said:

  But one had an 80% success rate of making the playoffs with Rivera. The other is still holding a donut in that category. So by YOUR criteria, one was much better than the other. 

Its fugging insane how people still support him

How short the memory

People practically BEGGED for him to be canned over Fox.  And when he was fired, it was dam near a parade downtown.  While people said was the greatest move the panthers ever made.

Now he's back.

Hasnt done anything game changer.

[Toomers]

1 minute ago, Smithers said:

One of the best draft classes this team has seen in a long time.  Moore, Thomas, and Jackson look legit.  Anything else will be a bonus.

You mean since the year before. Not exactly a long time.

[Smithers]

1 minute ago, Toomers said:

You mean since the year before. Not exactly a long time.

I said “one of the best.”  I didn’t say the best.  

[Toomers]

1 minute ago, Smithers said:

I said “one of the best.”  I didn’t say the best.  

 If you acknowledge that the year before was superior, what was the purpose of the statement?  What is the long time comment then? 

[Cpt slay a ho]

4 minutes ago, Toomers said:

  But one had an 80% success rate of making the playoffs with Rivera. The other is still holding a donut in that category. So by YOUR criteria, one was much better than the other. 

And like I said both sucked, one suck less then the other sure but is that saying a lot, not really

[Snake]

Cam,Luke,Olson,Thomas,Jackson,Moore,and CMC. Not really a bad track record honestly and I'm definitely not a Hurney Homer. Find a coach who can actually help develop talent and you might have a winning combination.

[Toomers]

5 minutes ago, Cpt slay a ho said:

And like I said both sucked, one suck less then the other sure but is that saying a lot, not really

Considering the one that was more successful did it while making up for the ineptitude of the other...Yes it is saying a lot. One had a new job in 6 months. One hasn’t been contacted by another NFL team in 20 years. 

  I guess I could just be lazy and say everyone sux too. My bad.

[Toomers]

10 minutes ago, Snake said:

Cam,Luke,Olson,Thomas,Jackson,Moore,and CMC. Not really a bad track record honestly and I'm definitely not a Hurney Homer. Find a coach who can actually help develop talent and you might have a winning combination.

Well. Let’s see. 

CMC- uhhh what?

Cam and Luke were signed to very good contracts by DG. What would they have been if Hurney negotiated them? Something like Olsen’s, which will cost us 7.4M when Olsen doesn’t play. Great extension there. 

And three rookies. 

  5 straight years without making playoffs. The current coach had very little trouble making the playoffs with another GM. 

[Gucceland]

LOL

[Cpt slay a ho]

2 minutes ago, Toomers said:

Considering the one that was more successful did it while making up for the ineptitude of the other...Yes it is saying a lot. One had a new job in 6 months. One hasn’t been contacted by another NFL team in 20 years. 

  I guess I could just be lazy and say everyone sux too. My bad.

You’re changing this into yet the 50th millionth Hurney vs Dg debate that I’m quite frankly not up for since I could care less for both. Cool dg got another job with the giants congrats to him, but some of the moves he made and picks he made before his departure have hampered the team, it is what it is both failed to bring a trophy to Charlotte