CMC the best threat the Panthers have ever had?

[pantherj]

Just now, WarPanthers89 said:

I agree with you about Smith. It’s wild to think though that as dominate as Smith was, CMC can have more yards this season than Smith ever had. 

CMC reminds me a little bit of Warrick Dunn. They both have that inhumanly fast muscle twitch so their legs just explode with quickness, and they're both tough as nails and absorb a ton of punishment somehow. Smith had the disadvantage of being taken out of games with triple coverage, or Jake pooping the bed. If Smith had Brees throwing to him over his career he'd be considered one the best WRs to ever play the game.

[The Huddler]

id go with Cam

[t96]

Non-QB I’d say he’s already 2nd behind Smitty, but if he has games like that Seahawks game more consistently he’ll be the best no question. Incl. QBs, obviously Cam is #1.

[Carl Spackler]

Cam

[NcPsa10]

“Christian McCaffrey has been so extraordinary… He is on pace to shatter Marshall Faulk’s season averages.”

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Not bad 

[AggieLean]

Nah, Cam and Smith

[Peppers90 NC]

When and if he is ever able to finish those beautlong plays for scores, then he will have passed Smitty.

[Hoenheim]

Hes having ONE great season while Steve Smith had a HoF career with several of them. 
Id also say Smith was had more big play ability and was more explosive in his prime. 

 

[bigdog10]

Idk, but I’m watching Fournette getting stuffed twice by the Titans and can’t get over how wrong I was in wanting him over CMac. 

We got ourselves a good one. 

[jfra78]

Its Smitty

But the real question is can DJ be more of a threat than Smitty was?

[Mr. Scot]

Warrrick Dunn is a good comparison.

Regarding the comparison to Smith, no he's not there yet but there is something to think about on that front. 

Steve Smith wasn't "Steve Smith" during the first two years of his career.  He didn't really hit his stride till year three.  McCaffrey's already doing amazing things and his second season isn't even done yet.

If you look at it in terms of career progression, McCaffrey is well ahead of where Smith was at the same point in his career.

[Wolfpredator]

CMC is a one man wrecking crew. This past off season did wonders for him and he has improved in nearly every area.  Would love to see him take a few of those long plays to the house, really my only knock. 

[NcPsa10]

CmC Pro-bowl votes /Magic Inc <-------

hmm graham gano just for lol ;)>?

Dj more ? tell me .......... 

[rico6]

5 hours ago, pantherj said:

CMC reminds me a little bit of Warrick Dunn. They both have that inhumanly fast muscle twitch so their legs just explode with quickness, and they're both tough as nails and absorb a ton of punishment somehow. Smith had the disadvantage of being taken out of games with triple coverage, or Jake pooping the bed. If Smith had Brees throwing to him over his career he'd be considered one the best WRs to ever play the game.

Dunn was so underrated.