Eric Reid deserves a long-term contract

[Sam Mills Fan]

2 minutes ago, Nice-Carolina-Chuck said:

Roman Harper was better than Reid. Coleman was better. 

Reid just made us feel better that we didnt have go see Jones and Searcy. 

You don't actually believe that. I won't even entertain Harper. Coleman: he made a living here by having soft hands that let him pick off a lot of passes. He obviously has better hands than Reid. But Coleman wasn't nearly as good against the run and got burned in coverage even more than Reid.

[Oldmanrivera]

5 minutes ago, Nice-Carolina-Chuck said:

Roman Harper was better than Reid. Coleman was better. 

Reid just made us feel better that we didnt have go see Jones and Searcy. 

Seriously, you can sit with a straight face and say Roman Harper is better? 

[4Corners]

6 minutes ago, Nice-Carolina-Chuck said:

Roman Harper was better than Reid. Coleman was better. 

 

Carolina Chuck is back, baby!

Hot takes for days!

[GoobyPls]

4 minutes ago, Oldmanrivera said:

Seriously, you can sit with a straight face and say Roman Harper is better? 

 

6 minutes ago, Sam Mills Fan said:

You don't actually believe that. I won't even entertain Harper. Coleman: he made a living here by having soft hands that let him pick off a lot of passes. He obviously has better hands than Reid. But Coleman wasn't nearly as good against the run and got burned in coverage even more than Reid.

Harper was way better than Reid in coverage, way better

 

Harpers problem was that he was slower than molasses, but he was never getting burned as much as Reid is now.

[SOJA]

For sure, but one thing is certain. He's definitely a SS. 

 

My dream for this offseason is we nab a DE, ball hawking FS (Panthers have never really had an Ed Reed type player), and NB

Combine that with Bradberry (average player), Reid (above average SS), Action Jackson (going to be a stud) we would have a fantastic secondary 

[trueblade]

I've seen him take some poor angles on the big runs against us, but I could just be remembering a couple of plays. I don't study the All 22. I do worry he's a Personal Foul penalty waiting to happen and could have easily had one in the Tampa game.

[Shocker]

3 hours ago, Sam Mills Fan said:

To anyone saying we shouldn't re-sign him because he hasn't been perfect, can you name a better safety than him that we've had since freaking Mike Minter retired 100 years ago?

LOL...Adams

[Definitely Not Trolling]

3 hours ago, Sam Mills Fan said:

To anyone saying we shouldn't re-sign him because he hasn't been perfect, can you name a better safety than him that we've had since freaking Mike Minter retired 100 years ago?

Coleman, Mitchell, Chris Harris

[luke nukem]

like someone else said, get a real FS and a good Nickle and Im willing to go with another prove it deal. If you think about it we are the only team that considered signing him, as fuged up as it sounds we have wayyy more leverage here than the average Free Agent. I would offer him a 1 year 3.56 million dollar prove it deal.

[Snake]

He's a throw back SS that hasn't really played that great. So no I rather draft a Safety that actually fits the NFL now not in 1960.

[luke nukem]

Also Roman Harper May not have played better than Reid while he was here but he is without a doubt the better player overall. Was a Beast in NO the year they won there superbowl... another thing he has that we will never get :(

[Car123]

5 minutes ago, Snake said:

He's a throw back SS that hasn't really played that great. So no I rather draft a Safety that actually fits the NFL now not in 1960.

Adams is probably gone next year. You want us to draft two safeties? That's a recipe for disaster.

[rippadonn]

Way above average.

Yes, politics is biting a chunk out of his ars. I like the fact that he won't back down, nothing more American than that. He's a thumper. When he hits you, you've been hit. His style of play reminds me of TD.

I love the fact Tepper would sign the guy and officially say f' the BS.

[4Corners]

7 minutes ago, Billy_T said:

What's the market?  How much dough and for how long?

Google is your friend