Jump to content
  • Welcome!

    Register and log in easily with Twitter or Google accounts!

    Or simply create a new Huddle account. 

    Members receive fewer ads , access our dark theme, and the ability to join the discussion!

     

Could Rip Scherer be part of Jakes problem


jpo287

Recommended Posts

First off, I am not a Jake apologist and and not looking for excuses. I realize that Jake's problems started last year against Arizona. But usually, Jake has a bad game and then bounces back after a game or two. Needless to say, there hasn't been any bounce back this year. And while Jake has never been a great QB, he has always been better than what we are seeing this year. So I got to thinking and am wondering if the new QB coach, Rip Scherer, could be part of the problem.

I looked up his numbers while in Cleveland. In the four years he was the QB coach, they threw 70 TD's to 82 INT's. Of course he didn't have the best talent to start with but still, 70 TDs to 82 INTS! And this was across all four years he was there. In fact, they threw more INTs than TD's in three of his four years. So, could Scherer be part of the problem with Jake this year? His QBs do have a history of being turnover prone.

Again, I am not looking for excuses...just wondering???

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I still think Jake really started looking awful after his tommy john surgery. Quite sad too since right before he was injured he looked better than he ever has before.

Even last year he had his share of bad games.

Actually Jake wasn't too bad last year. He had the bad game against Tampa and Oakland throwing 7 INT in those two games. He only threw 12 INTs all year though which means he only threw 5 INT in the other 14 games. And how about those passes in the final seconds of the Chargers games, or against the Saints or his game against GB. I know Jake gets beat up all lot around here but you can't really say he had a bad year last year. You can say he had two bad games but two games do not make a year.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Actually Jake wasn't too bad last year. He had the bad game against Tampa and Oakland throwing 7 INT in those two games. He only threw 12 INTs all year though which means he only threw 5 INT in the other 14 games. And how about those passes in the final seconds of the Chargers games, or against the Saints or his game against GB. I know Jake gets beat up all lot around here but you can't really say he had a bad year last year. You can say he had two bad games but two games do not make a year.

Finally some facts and actual information instead of the usual hysterical commentary. :hurray:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

He isn't the one overthrowing, underthrowing, lame-duck throwing, and in general making poor choices/throws. He might not be helping a whole lot, but I wouldn't put much (if any) of the blame on him for the inept passing offense.

Isn't that kind of like saying Fox doesn't deserve any of the criticism for the teams poor play. After all, he's not making them miss blocks or tackles.

Look, all I am saying is maybe he came in and started changing Jake's mechanics or something. We all know they weren't great to start with. But as bad as they were, he was still able to connect with Smith almost at will. Now, there's nothing. It can't be the surgery because he was fine last year. The only other major change, other than age, is the QB coach.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.


  • PMH4OWPW7JD2TDGWZKTOYL2T3E.jpg

  • Topics

  • Posts

    • Happy Thanksgiving y’all. Thankful for a very good team and for this group to talk canes.  Eat drink celebrate our win bs the rags. This team is cup ready. 
    • I don't think should be seen as an insult, legitimately. Teddy's floor was consistently a good game manager to his ceiling of border-line top 10 QB who's arm strength didn't blow you away but could make all the throws and generally made good decisions and had some sneaky athleticism.  Teddy started on quite a few teams. He had a good start to his career, had a horrific injury that could have ended his career, came back and played himself into being a starter, got a contract here (and subsequently became another victim of Tepper's impetuousness), and then started games for a few other teams. Teddy could have been a franchise QB had he not suffered a freak injury, and then he just never ended up in another stable situation. He still had a good NFL career that could have been great without that injury. Teddy before that injury did look like a franchise QB, and I dont think that's a bad comp for Young nor an insult in terms of what his career could be based on that comparison.
    • Absolutely the wrong take. We have to run and gun. We have zero post presence. We just have to make shots. We just can't hit water from a boat tonight and we're turning it over to boot. Then you have a poor shooting opponent shooting lights out.  Looks like a long season ahead of us though if Hubert doesn't adapt to this roster. We have to play a pressure trapping D and get out in transition because we aren't beating anyone in the half court.
×
×
  • Create New...