Game of Thrones - Season 8

[CRA]

4 minutes ago, CarolinaCoolin said:

Where are you getting this and why are you using your opinion to try to discredit a theory?

i don’t get it. 

George RR Martin said the faces they use belonged to the dead.   The theory is based on them cloning the living. 

I merely said, HBO the TV show fugging up one scene wasn't enough to throw everything out the window the books, the TV show, and Martin himself have said or illustrated about how they operate w/ the faces. 

[Zaximus]

14 minutes ago, CRA said:

George RR Martin said the faces they use belonged to the dead.   The theory is based on them cloning the living. 

I merely said, HBO the TV show fugging up one scene wasn't enough to throw everything out the window the books, the TV show, and Martin himself have said or illustrated about how they operate w/ the faces. 

Well we seen on the show something that's contrary to that.

I think perhaps the faceless men are using magic to do what they do but keeping the faces is almost a "symbolic" thing in the House of Black and White.     Jaqen changes his his face at will in a scene where I don't think he has time to pull a physical mask out.     I kind of think the physical faces is more like a temple to their sacrifice to the many faced God.   

But like, there's no reason for everyone to get mad at each other over GoT theories lol.

[CRA]

3 minutes ago, Zaximus said:

Well we seen on the show something that's contrary to that.

I think perhaps the faceless men are using magic to do what they do but keeping the faces is almost a "symbolic" thing in the House of Black and White.     Jaqen changes his his face at will in a scene where I don't think he has time to pull a physical mask out.     I kind of think the physical faces is more like a temple to their sacrifice to the many faced God.   

But like, there's no reason for everyone to get mad at each other over GoT theories lol.

Coolin just bringing that Tinderbox heat at me. 

I just want something besides Dany and Jon living happily ever after to be honest.    well... or Bran ending up being the central everything explanation

at much rather the LF theory come to fruition than that. 

 

[CarolinaCoolin]

15 minutes ago, CRA said:

George RR Martin said the faces they use belonged to the dead.   The theory is based on them cloning the living. 

I merely said, HBO the TV show fugging up one scene wasn't enough to throw everything out the window the books, the TV show, and Martin himself have said or illustrated about how they operate w/ the faces. 

The show and the books are two entirely different things. You also are pulling these Martin quotes from where? Have you read the books? It isn’t just one scene. It was an entire season plot ark and fuging up a major character. 

 

This theory makes more sense than what they did and it isn’t the first time they’ve killed major character in a bad out of character way. 

 

 

we are talking the character that influenced the war of the 5 kings and kicked the whole plot off. But he gets out smarted by the stark kids? That’s out of character completely. I’m not sure you fully understand what you are watching man

[CRA]

14 minutes ago, CarolinaCoolin said:

The show and the books are two entirely different things. You also are pulling these Martin quotes from where? Have you read the books? It isn’t just one scene. It was an entire season plot ark and fuging up a major character. 

 

This theory makes more sense than what they did and it isn’t the first time they’ve killed major character in a bad out of character way. 

 

 

we are talking the character that influenced the war of the 5 kings and kicked the whole plot off. But he gets out smarted by the stark kids? That’s out of character completely. I’m not sure you fully understand what you are watching man

there is a video Martin talks about the faces.  It was while the show was going on and not form the pre-show era.  Found it when I read this theory awhile back and was thinking about it. 

 that might be a little unjust to say he got outsmarted by these "meddling kids".  I mean look at the journey of those 3 and what they all went through and had to become in order to bring LF down.   There basically a mini-Avenger squad at this point.   I mean, you might be overpowering LF at this stage in the game.   

[Still Brooklyn]

I just want Bran to die. The only character (ever) I can't stand.

[CarolinaCoolin]

1 hour ago, CRA said:

there is a video Martin talks about the faces.  It was while the show was going on and not form the pre-show era.  Found it when I read this theory awhile back and was thinking about it. 

 that might be a little unjust to say he got outsmarted by these "meddling kids".  I mean look at the journey of those 3 and what they all went through and had to become in order to bring LF down.   There basically a mini-Avenger squad at this point.   I mean, you might be overpowering LF at this stage in the game.   

Post the video. Otherwise I’m not going to keep arguing against your opinions that you hold as fact pretty much. I do that enough as it is

[Zaximus]

15 hours ago, CRA said:

Coolin just bringing that Tinderbox heat at me. 

I just want something besides Dany and Jon living happily ever after to be honest.    well... or Bran ending up being the central everything explanation

at much rather the LF theory come to fruition than that. 

 

I don't think both live, I think in fact one may fall to the other.

LF started the entire Game of Thrones so I definitely would find it odd for him to be out so quick but who knows.    I don't expect him to win, I don't expect anyone to win honestly not like we would think, but I'm not sure he's out.     Even if he's not dead though, I'm not sure what pull he'll have since he's lost his army anyway.

[CRA]

16 hours ago, CarolinaCoolin said:

Post the video. Otherwise I’m not going to keep arguing against your opinions that you hold as fact pretty much. I do that enough as it is

 

 

 

[natty]

I like the theory that it wasn't actually Littlefinger that died but I think there's zero chance is plays out like that in the show.  

One theory I really like that's 100% plausible is that LF played an important part in starting Robert's Rebellion too.  After the tourney at Harrenhall Brandon Stark heads off to Riverrun to spend time with Cat before their wedding.  This is when LF challenges him, gets his ass kicked and Cat has to beg Brandon not to kill him.  During his recovery he gets Lysa pregnant, causing a bunch of drama and Hoster Tully kicks him out.  This also enrages Brandon and he leaves Riverrun for a bit(it's never said why but probably to chase down LF and finish what he started).  The tourney was held during a false spring so by this time the winter snows have returned closing off the path to the Vale and LF is most likely bunkering down at the inn at the crossroads.  Meanwhile, Lyanna meets up with Rhaegar at some point, most likely just to run off and have a fling for a couple weeks.  Lyanna was staying at Harrenhall and the closest place to meet up without being noticed is the inn at the crossroads(it's actually said they meet "ten leagues from Harrenhall").  So LF sees them meet up and take off(he would certainly recognize them while they probably wouldn't know who he is).  A little while later Brandon comes storming in wanting to kill LF.  So LF, in a panic, thinks of the only thing he can to divert his anger elsewhere - "Rhaegar just abducted your sister".

[CarolinaCoolin]

59 minutes ago, CRA said:

 

 

 

This is George talking about Arya as it is in the books. The show is a different thing entirely 

[PurityControl]

On 4/11/2019 at 10:16 AM, Dex said:

 

 

Gift from boss after one of my bottles of scotch went missing.

Got a bottle of this for xmas, wasn't going to drink it, then I opened up another gift that were some panther shot glasses, and one thing lead to another. 

Bottle gone.

It was some rough juice even being frozen AF like it supposed to be. 

But after 5-6 you don't notice it anymore.

 

[Goondal]

To me it would be silly if Littlefinger was alive at this point.  I also think it does make sense that Sansa be a part of his eventual downfall.  I do understand those that are upset by it.  The way it happened was stupid, poorly executed, and felt rushed.  In that way it fit in nicely with S7.

It was stupid that all of Dorne, which was at full strength and not fought a battle, was taken out in one scene.  It was stupid that all of Highgarden was taken off the board in one silly montage with a Tyrion voiceover where he sounds like a terrible strategist.  It was stupid that Bronn a Jamie survived that battle, and the whole capture a wight plan was dumb beyond belief.

I feel as if things were just too big and they decided ”we need to cut things down to just the necessary people, get them in two place, and the Night King needs a dragon,” and they crammed all that in to seven episodes the best they could...which was not well.

[Still Brooklyn]

A GOT writer listed episodes that everyone should re-watch before tomorrow. The episode where Arya spies on Littlefinger was not one of them.