Delhomme vs. David Carr

[PuntJake]

Carr

4 of 5 72yds 1TD 0INT 158.3 Passer Rating

Delhomme

9 of 17 65yds 1TD 2INT 42.2 Passer Rating

:puke:

[natty]

Thanks for pointing out how worthless a stat QB ranking is.

[Panther_Fan]

Bleh i misread, Stats right, Jake SUCKS!!

In Carr's defense i will say our offensive line sucked when we had him.

[Saint J]

Carr played vs. backups.

[natty]

Don't get me wrong, Jake has completely lost it. But I don't need a QB rating to tell me that.

[PuntJake]

Carr played vs. backups.

backups on a tough saints defense. jake played against the bucs secondary who had been shredded all season.

[MurkN]

Didn't David Carr replace an injured Eli Manning earlier this season as well and also post some better numbers? I guess with the proper coaching any quarterback can become competent.

[monstercat]

David Carr has Hakeem Nicks to throw to. I wish T.J Yates still had Nicks to throw to right now.

[Jangler]

Why do I care about David Carr and his worthless 72 yards? Win>Loss hence Jake>David

[Superadiabatic]

Obviously, these are not lifetime stats.

I'd take even the Jake of today against Carr. Sorry, Mittens was one of this franchise's worst mistakes.

[Raleighcat83]

Yeah, Jake's been terrible this year and is probably done as a productive QB but this is a dumb comparison. We all saw how bad Carr was a couple years ago when the pressure was on in big situations against real defenses. I don't care what the rating was, he was the worst I've ever seen. There was no hope of actually scoring with him. What matters is whether Moore is better than Jake right now, I tend to think he probably is.

[Brooklyn Bully]

Didn't David Carr replace an injured Eli Manning earlier this season as well and also post some better numbers? I guess with the proper coaching any quarterback can become competent.

Yeah, I was thinking this earlier. Carr has looked decent in NY. He had his moments in Houston when his line didn't let him down to get smashed. Here? Pure crap. That speaks volumes.

[Miaoww]

Did you see the sack Carr took? Brings back memories - he felt a little pressure and panicked.