One year on: Rating Christian McCaffrey

[RetiredCollegeCoach]

Don't grade the draft pick - rate the player.

Give me 1-10 rating for his 2017 season, and a 1-10 rating for what you think his 2018 season will be.

Don't adjust for rookie status, just rate like you'd rate any player.

 

[luke nukem]

6/10.

[LinvilleGorge]

9/10 as a receiver

5/0 as a runner

But considering that Cam was our only effective runner last year I'm not aure how much of CMC's struggles as a runner can be put on him. None of the other RBs did anything either. He also showed definite improvement as a runner later in the season.

[bababoey]

R/10 = 2017.  FUG YEAH/22 =2018

[L-TownCat]

He was a damn good rookie.

7/10  could have been higher with more splash play TDs.

8/10 for 2018.  The big play TDs will begin.

[Mother Grabber]

he rates a solid chicken biriyani, i’m looking for pad kee mao this year.

[Manther]

Solid 8/10.  Reliable 3rd down conversion option.  How many first downs did he get us?  

[panthers55]

He gets a 7 out of 10. He started off slow but definitely improved as the season progressed. 

[Daddy_Uncle]

Moon butt

[Mikey815]

13 minutes ago, panthers55 said:

He gets a 7 out of 10. He started off slow but definitely improved as the season progressed. 

I would like to see him get about 15 carries a game instead of 7. Then you might see 1500 all purpose yarda

[The Huddler]

He was a 9.5/10 with his role as the 3rd down back. His recieving and coverting ability is insane. He is such a weapon to dump it to on a 3rd down. Watch his highlight tape.. almost ever play is a 1st down

 

due to his limited role with Stewart hogging snaps (unable to get in a grove or rythm which is important for a RB), and an OC that was a peanut brain, he didnt have a chance to shine as a workhorse RB

 

if he gets that opportunity this year to take most of the snaps and he can get to be THE guy, he will be a premiere back and one of the best in the league. 

 

He just needs the opportunity. 

[Khyber53]

8/10 for 2017. Haven't seen even close to his top end yet.

[joemac]

7.5/10 last year

9.5/10 this year. I'm expecting a YUGE year from CMC. I think Norv is the perfect OC to maximize his ability, and u think he will begin to light teams up next year. I expect to see a lot more plays like his long TD against the Saints in the playoffs.

[MHS831]

7.302