Comp Picks update

[t96]

1 minute ago, pantherclaw said:

Have to improve the team. Can't be worried about the comps.

Agree to a degree but you absolutely have to take it into consideration and weigh the costs and benefits. If it costs you the 3rd round comp pick to sign depth on the OL, that’s a bad move. If it costs you a 6th rounder to sign a solid CB to compete for the starting position, then that’s a great move.

[Dex]

[t96]

2 minutes ago, AU-panther said:

https://www.milehighreport.com/2014/3/18/5520508/how-do-compensatory-picks-work 

would support that 

Good find, I hope that’s right. So as of now we still have our Norwell comp pick, but not the Dickson one unless someone like DA signs elsewhere.

[The NFL Shield At Midfield]

1 minute ago, Dex said:

yeah no big deal i never wanted to have an erection ever again anyway

[pantherclaw]

7 minutes ago, thomas96 said:

Agree to a degree but you absolutely have to take it into consideration and weigh the costs and benefits. If it costs you the 3rd round comp pick to sign depth on the OL, that’s a bad move. If it costs you a 6th rounder to sign a solid CB to compete for the starting position, then that’s a great move.

I'm not saying to not consider it, but ya got to fill holes in free agency. 

A comp pick a year later isn't going to fill a hole this year. 

[AU-panther]

5 minutes ago, pantherclaw said:

I'm not saying to not consider it, but ya got to fill holes in free agency. 

A comp pick a year later isn't going to fill a hole this year. 

But it might fill a hole next year

And with the money you save by filling a hole with a rookie you can spend on another free agent.  Being competitive next year isn't always the same as being competitive the next 5 years.

Would you be happy trading next years 3rd for Jeremiah Sirles?

I agree that you don't always play the comp game but there are definitely years where based on the free agents you could lose it would benefit you to.

[La Pantera]

We should totally just resend our offers on the guys we just picked up. Gotta makes sure we get a 3rd round comp pick,.

[pantherclaw]

Yeah, let's not field a competitive team, wasting another year of Cam and Luke in their primes, all for a chance at a comp pick. 

fug that stupidity.

[TheCasillas]

54 minutes ago, thomas96 said:

Voth may be wrong. My understanding was always that untendered RFAs become UFAs. Voth may have, like Saca, thought Sirles was released. But he wasn’t.

Why cant you be wrong?

[Untouchable]

1 hour ago, thomas96 said:

Yep @Saca312 pretty sure untendered RFAs revert to UFAs.

They don't (at least as qualifying FAs for comp picks).  No worries, the 3rd is still in-tack.  And it is still more valuable than any of the free agents to be brought in at this point so I'd expect the team to keep it that way.  

[Leeroy Jenkins Ph.D.]

A restricted free agent who did not receive a RFA tender offer will not count in the comp pick calculation.

 

We are still set to receive our 3rd round pick for Norwell.

[t96]

6 minutes ago, TheCasillas said:

Why cant you be wrong?

By saying Voth may be wrong, one can logically deduce that I could be wrong as well.

[TheCasillas]

23 minutes ago, thomas96 said:

By saying Voth may be wrong, one can logically deduce that I could be wrong as well.

it just didn't need to be said man. It would have been much easier for you to google rather than dispute with limited knowledge. I will logically deduce that you didn't do your research before disagreeing with it.

 

Even prior to your comment @Saca312 shared that it wouldn't be held against our compensatory pick. Some times we just are not correct, its life. Stand by it.

[top dawg]

Be competent...

 

Anyway, the draft is a crap shoot. I'm not getting riled up over a third (or lower) round comp pick.