Who was the better Carolina Panther? Double-trouble addition

[Adb6368]

I've attached the stats but this is less about stats and more about who you thought was a better Panther. Not just on the field, but who will you remember made a bigger impact on the organization on the field and off. I know Deangelo become a huge B**** when he left but he was definitely butthurt. However, he essentially created the pink October campaign and was nothing but a model citizen while here. However, Stewart never cared about the spotlight and went out every day and gave 100%. So what say you? Who was the better Panther?

And Deangelo Williams (Carolina seasons only)

[Palmetto]

I'll go with Williams

[frash.exe]

meangelo could’ve done so much more here if he had the right attitude and kept his weight down and his conditioning up

[t96]

D-Will was better on the field. Stew was better all around.

[Cpt slay a ho]

Strictly from a a football perspective,Always said d will was better

[carolinapanther]

Hard choice. Have to go with Williams.

[OneBadCat]

Different style runners.

I think Stewart was better on the field and fought a lot harder. Stewart also lost a lot of snaps to Williams so we didn’t get to see the full scope of Stewart either. That run against the jags was amazing.

Deangelo had more transcendent talent in my opinion. I really haven’t seen a guy move the way he did since Barry Sanders, obviously not as good but similar moves and skills.

Both were have been top 5 RBs in the NFL if you separated them.

[KillerKat]

Look at the YPC

[SIGCHI222]

Williams.

[Still Brooklyn]

D-Lo

[Mol3m4n]

Additon:

JoAngethan Willwart

[carpanfan96]

Have to go with Williams, when he was given the rock during his prime he was a game breaker. Some of his cutbacks were amazing

[PantherNation123]

Tough to say - both had awesome years, but both I think ultimately underperformed what they could've been, and what they showed flashes of (and in Jstew's case, the amount of injuries counts against him)

[JARROD]

Stewart,... not even close. Stewart pounded them so Deangelo was able to be more of that scat change of pace guy.