Takeaways from MNF

[TheCasillas]

5 minutes ago, JakeDel5674 said:

Right now I would say Kareem Hunt, LOL.  Or Marcus Lattimore.  Hindsight is 50/50 (thanks Cam), ya know?  But yeah, there has been a ton of players better than CMC that are Rookies right now.  Can't say Fournette, because he was picked before us (even though he's clearly been better, and would be better for this team).    

Kareem Hunt wasn't a 1st round pick. 3rd round. What my point is that we can't say CMC is average for where he was drafted when he is outplaying the rest of the rookie talent on offense. His stats are on par for a normal successful rookie year, his on the field play is vet like. The kid just understands the game. You cant take that away fro him.

[TheCasillas]

4 minutes ago, JakeDel5674 said:

And no, I don't consider him "God awful", Electro does, which I said in a previous post.  Do you even read properly bro?  

did you see my corrected post? So eager to get aggressive. Be calm.

[JakeDel5674]

2 minutes ago, TheCasillas said:

Kareem Hunt wasn't a 1st round pick. 3rd round. What my point is that we can't say CMC is average for where he was drafted when he is outplaying the rest of the rookie talent on offense. His stats are on par for a normal successful rookie year, his on the field play is vet like. The kid just understands the game. You cant take that away fro him.

Doesn't matter if Kareem Hunt was a 3rd round pick or not.  He's been amazing.  And yes, he's been average at best for all the touches he has received.  That's great that he understands the game, that he loves life, and that he is a cool dude.  But, he's been an average player AT BEST (so far).  Simple as that.  

[JakeDel5674]

1 minute ago, TheCasillas said:

did you see my corrected post? So eager to get aggressive. Be calm.

I did not see your corrected post, my fault.  

[ecu88]

Yards yards blah 

CMC's blocking, decoying, sure hands, yac, and his team first attitude is all I need to know he will make our team better.

Kareem Hunt has been slowing down lately 

[TheCasillas]

2 minutes ago, JakeDel5674 said:

Doesn't matter if Kareem Hunt was a 3rd round pick or not.  He's been amazing.  And yes, he's been average at best for all the touches he has received.  That's great that he understands the game, that he loves life, and that he is a cool dude.  But, he's been an average player AT BEST.  Simple as that.  

it does matter because my question to was what first round player has played better than CMC? Not to discredit your reading like you did to mine. Listen man, the bottom line is this.... you are alone or at most with electro's horse in this argument. TBH alone or with electro's horse are both sad places to be.

We as Panther fans believe that CMC was worth it. He has done more than you can ask for a rookie. 

 

[electro's horse]

I’ve never said that he’s godawful btw 

just that he was a dumb pick for the offense, wasn’t worth the draft position, and that his defenders will tie themselves into knots justifying his selection. 

Which hey continues to be right!

three best offensive performances of the year have barely involved him. Sure that’s just a coincidence though. 

[electro's horse]

4 minutes ago, TheCasillas said:

We as Panther fans believe that CMC was worth it. He has done more than you can ask for a rookie. 

 

Lol on a team with two rookies of the year middling production is more than we can ask for. 

Sure guy, thanks. 

[TheCasillas]

5 minutes ago, electro's horse said:

Lol on a team with two rookies of the year middling production is more than we can ask for. 

Sure guy, thanks. 

what?

[electro's horse]

Just now, TheCasillas said:

what?

You said more than you can ask. 

Actually no panthers fans especially can expect something more from rookies. 

[JakeDel5674]

6 minutes ago, TheCasillas said:

it does matter because my question to was what first round player has played better than CMC? Not to discredit your reading like you did to mine. Listen man, the bottom line is this.... you are alone or at most with electro's horse in this argument. TBH alone or with electro's horse are both sad places to be.

We as Panther fans believe that CMC was worth it. He has done more than you can ask for a rookie. 

 

I mean, UNC said he hasn't been good either.  I'm just logical man, and many other First Rounders and other round Draft picks have been better.  

 

Here, I'll name all the First Round Rookies for you that have been better or had more of an impact on both sides of the ball, so far.

DeShaun Watson (Rookie of the Year before he got hurt), Jamal Adams, Marshon Lattimore, Fournette (clearly), and lastly, TJ Watt.  McCaffrey has been average, and that's okay.  But, he's not even in the running for  Rookie of the Year right now.  All have been better than CMC.  Regardless, as long as we keep winning, I don't really care how he does.      

[electro's horse]

Hooker too before he died. 

[TheCasillas]

3 minutes ago, JakeDel5674 said:

I mean, UNC said he hasn't been good either.  I'm just logical man, and many other First Rounders and other round Draft picks have been better.  

 

Here, I'll name all the First Round Rookies for you that have been better or had more of an impact on both sides of the ball, so far.

DeShaun Watson (Rookie of the Year before he got hurt), Jamal Adams, Marshon Lattimore, Fournette (clearly), and lastly, TJ Watt.  McCaffrey has been average, and that's okay.  But, he's not even in the running for  Rookie of the Year right now.  All have been better than CMC.  Regardless, as long as we keep winning, I don't really care how he does.      

only 2 of those are offensive players. 1 is a qb (which we dont need) So... what I am understanding, even if we include defense..... CMC was the 6th best player taken in the first round at pick #8? Interesting.......

Also, vegas odds as of this morning has CMC as third in ROTY. So he is trending up if people are beginning to gamble on him right?

[electro's horse]

1 minute ago, TheCasillas said:

only 2 of those are offensive players. 1 is a qb (which we dont need) So... what I am understanding, even if we include defense..... CMC was the 6th best player taken in the first round at pick #8? Interesting.......

Also, vegas odds as of this morning has CMC as third in ROTY. So he is trending up if people are beginning to gamble on him right?

Yeah enough players get hurt his chances will improve.