Peppers vs. Kuechly

[HeroesHealers2]

I was called a troll earlier for saying Peppers is the best player the Panthers have ever had. Many said Luke Kuechly was the best ever.

I think today proved who has had the better career.

[PhillyB]

it's pep and that's not debatable by anyone with a brain

[YoungPanthers89]

Holy poo stop making threads

[HeroesHealers2]

Just now, PhillyB said:

it's pep and that's not debatable by anyone with a brain

Tell that to the legion of people calling me a troll.

[Jackofalltrades]

Just now, HeroesHealers2 said:

I was called a troll earlier for saying Peppers is the best player the Panthers have ever had. Many said Luke Kuechly was the best ever.

I think today proved who has had the better career.

Impossible to compare careers at this point. You could also put Cam or Steve Smith into the conversation and it's still a tough call because of tenure and their jobs. 

[Fox007]

How is this guy comparing careers to someone at the end of theirs to someone at the beginning of theirs. WTF is honestly going on around here.

[Kevin Greene]

Time to reinstitute the minimum post/topic ability rule.

[mav1234]

it's too early to compare Luke or Cam to Pep... Smitty might be up there with Pep.  Would need to look closely at both their stats...

[Floppin]

Just now, HeroesHealers2 said:

Tell that to the legion of people calling me a troll.

You were called a troll for saying Stafford is the best lion ever, not for your comments about pep/keek.

[Jangler]

I hope the have a soul kiss on thursday

[NavyPF4L]

1 minute ago, PhillyB said:

it's pep and that's not debatable by anyone with a brain

As of late you aren't one of those that fits the mold. 

 

We were still competitive without Pep. Luke however without him it's more of a dumpster fire

[HeroesHealers2]

Just now, NavyPF4L said:

As of late you aren't one of those that fits the mold. 

 

We were still competitive without Pep. Luke however without him it's more of a dumpster fire

We went 4-0 without Luke in the Super Bowl year...

[L-TownCat]

1 minute ago, NavyPF4L said:

As of late you aren't one of those that fits the mold. 

 

We were still competitive without Pep. Luke however without him it's more of a dumpster fire

To be fair it's not the importance that is in question it's more sustained excellence.

Luke - 6 seasons

Pep - 16 seasons (or close to that I can't remember)

[AceBoogie]

It’s Cam, and it really ain’t a hard question.