Cam's QBR this week is 7. Is it time to sit him down?

[raleigh-panther]

Cam is a shell of what he used to be

it is clear that shoulder is not well and there has to be other things going on

should the Panthers follow Indy's lead and sit him Down?

really starting to be concerned about how he is managed

we aren't winning with him in this  condition 

[UnluckyCharms]

1 minute ago, raleigh-panther said:

Cam is a shell of what he used to be

it is clear that shoulder is not well and there has to be other things going on

should the Panthers follow Indy's lead and sit him Down?

really starting to be concerned about how he is managed

we aren't winning with him in this  condition 

We won twice with him in this condition

[tiger7_88]

Just now, raleigh-panther said:

Cam is a shell of what he used to be

it is clear that shoulder is not well and there has to be other things going on

should the Panthers follow Indy's lead and sit him Down?

really starting to be concerned about how he is managed

we aren't winning with him in this  condition 

Cam was awful yesterday.

That doesn't make QBR any less of a poo stat.

[Camp Fodder]

Just now, UnluckyCharms said:

We won twice with him in this condition

Not due to his stellar play

[Snake]

I can promise if you put Anderson in there his will be lower. Not the QB but the system. JR doesn't fire you for incompetents. 

[UnluckyCharms]

1 minute ago, Camp Fodder said:

Not due to his stellar play

Still won lol. OP said we aren't winning with him in this condition but we did it twice.

[dldove77]

The only logical question would be: "Is it time to trade him and draft a new QB?", because what's behind Cam right now isn't better. 

Note: I am not advocating trading Cam.

Yet.

[UncleWillie]

He needs to run more, especially toward the edges with his speed. Cams legs are good but he needs to get out of that pocket to protect his shoulder.

[raleigh-panther]

5 minutes ago, UnluckyCharms said:

We won twice with him in this condition

That isnt the point here. In neither did he look stellar anyway

I am not a big believer in setting players up to fail and that is what is happening here

 

[DelhommesTheMan]

It’s time to face facts that Cam isn’t ready to play.  This is not the Cam Newton we have seen in the past.  He doesn’t even have is strength down overthrowing everyone and his accuracy is worse than ever.  If we are going to be successful we have to do what the bears did to the Steelers yesterday, and what we did against Buffalo and SF.  That’s run, run and run some more.  We will go as far as the defense and our two headed monster of Rbs will take us.  Welcome back to Fox ball, except it’s actually our only shot until Cam gets back to form and it’s football we can actually be successful playing with our current team construction.

[Growl]

7 minutes ago, Snake said:

I can promise if you put Anderson in there his will be lower. Not the QB but the system. JR doesn't fire you for incompetents. 

I really don't think this is true to be honest.

 

Anderson may not be the talent Cam is but he has also proven he can come out and efficiently distribute the ball and not eat sacks.

 

When Cam plays we either win games or lose them dependent upon him. Anderson can play within a system.

[Captain Obvious]

Cam doesn't trust his tackles. Hard to be accurate then both eyes are glancing at the end of the oline. You know he is thinking of last year and thinking, oh no,not again. He may have ptsd from the hits he took last year

[raleigh-panther]

5 minutes ago, UnluckyCharms said:

Still won lol. OP said we aren't winning with him in this condition but we did it twice.

My point to you. And you know it, so no need to be cute, the upcoming games against, NE, Det, Philly, Atl, are. not winnable with what we are seeing here

yes, against two earlier teams, the Panthers won but we saw the missed throws and other issues, a healthy Newton does not do those things

whyallow him to beaten up further? Give that shoulder rest may benefit the rest of the season

i truly feel the Panthers have mishandled him and he probably has two years tops left as this comtinues

[raleigh-panther]

11 minutes ago, Snake said:

I can promise if you put Anderson in there his will be lower. Not the QB but the system. JR doesn't fire you for incompetents. 

I know and their decision to keep Anderson is on their hands too