Shepard needs to show up and play

[MCC]

Let's be honest, DA and Joe Webb are not the strongest quarterbacks and rarely get passed the 1st WR in their progression.  

I'll hold out judgement for the entire offense until Cam is playing in the regular season. 

[KillerKat]

1 hour ago, Jeremy Igo said:

 

Yeah, fans and their annoying optimism. Amiright?

Yeah but there are 2 sides of the coin here. You can't make those threads and then tell everyone "go watch film" about someone else when really it's youtube highlights and gifs while you were majorly wrong about another player a couple months ago.

Optimism and making those threads are fine. But then playing the "holier than thou" card when others think differently is not.

[KillerKat]

6 hours ago, Saca312 said:

It's kind of funny how you're the one having a knee jerk reaction on Shepard after just two preseason games where Derek Anderson was legitimately bad and calling me out like I evaluated him wrong or something.

Two. Preseason. Games. Versus. His 2016 Season + Training Camp. 

I'll go with the larger sample size, my own analysis, and the people who actually went to training camp and say he was good and will have a roster spot.

I'm done talking about this. I'll just let you eat crow and complain when Shepard turns out to be a fine WR3 for us and not just a special teamer. 

Byrd and KB shined with the same QB.

[Jeremy Igo]

8 minutes ago, KillerKat said:

Byrd and KB shined with the same QB.

....that they have had a ton of time with over the years. 

[Saca312]

@KillerKat Majorly wrong about another player? How so?q

And lol. I don't look up youtube highlights. There aren't any for Shepard that I know of either, especially in All-22.

Oh, and I never began this conversation. It's when people decide to call me out in threads they make for no good reason that are tiring.

And clearly you don't understand DA's lack of a read progression and how he targets only specific players.

[csx]

3 minutes ago, KillerKat said:

Byrd and KB shined with the same QB.

Yes. Chemistry is different between different players. Though did Bryd catch anything from Anderson or was that mostly all Webb? 

[KillerKat]

15 minutes ago, Jeremy Igo said:

....that they have had a ton of time with over the years. 

But Shep apparently has shined in camp. If he wasn't on the same page with the QBs, he wouldn't. He just hasn't shown up yet in real games.

[KillerKat]

15 minutes ago, Saca312 said:

@KillerKat Majorly wrong about another player? How so?q

And lol. I don't look up youtube highlights. There aren't any for Shepard that I know of either, especially in All-22.

Oh, and I never began this conversation. It's when people decide to call me out in threads they make for no good reason that are tiring.

And clearly you don't understand DA's lack of a read progression and how he targets only specific players.

People call you out because you have an elitist attitude whenever someone disagrees with you.

[csx]

5 minutes ago, KillerKat said:

But Shep apparently has shined in camp. If he wasn't on the same page with the QBs, he wouldn't. He just hasn't shown up yet in real games.

We've yet to play a real game and not any fake games with the QB that he showed chemistry with.

[Jeremy Igo]

20 minutes ago, KillerKat said:

People call you out because you have an elitist attitude whenever someone disagrees with you.

He has looked very good all offseason. If you were there to see it I suspect you would be ok with people showing excitement over him. 

[Saca312]

18 minutes ago, KillerKat said:

People call you out because you have an elitist attitude whenever someone disagrees with you.

An elitist attitude? Lol what?

I generally don't go off unless someone calls me out. And top dawg decided to do that on the first page.

So then I defended my opinion. That is all. I appreciate actual debate and intelligent discussion, but I'm just seeing a user who has an agenda against me. 

 

[Hogmolliesmaht]

If only there was an example of a Panthers WR who started out as a full time STer for his first 3 seasons but ended up being a pretty darn good WR...

[csx]

At this stage what matters for him is to impress the coaches, front office, and his teammates. If he is truly doing that I don't care what he does in practice games. During the regular season of course I want to see him helping the team.

[Saca312]

4 minutes ago, csx said:

At this stage what matters for him is to impress the coaches, front office, and his teammates. If he is truly doing that I don't care what he does in practice games. During the regular season of course I want to see him helping the team.

This. x100.