Tell Me Which One Means More To You

[beastson]

Steve Young was talking about if Smith was in the west coast he would have 180 catches

Now I ask what do you notice more

A lot of receptions with a lot of yards, pretty much ignoring the average per catch

or

Not a lot of receptions but a lot of yards, paying attention to the average per catch

[megadeth078]

average per catch of course

[beastson]

You know when I used to play madden back in like 02 or something, I seen Harrison had 147 catches and 1700 yards. And I said wow man, thats amazing. So I always payed close to attention to both

But now, I see a lot of receivers with about average receptions and big yards. Like Smith of course. After hearing Young, I said whats the point of a lot of receptions when the yards and td's are coming with less receptions

[Brooklyn Bully]

But it's SMITH...giving HIM more receptions will lead to more yards after said catch. I don't care what system you put him in. Young was VERY VERY complimentary of Smitty after the Bucs game on the postgame show and said "if he gets the ball more he'd be unstoppable".

[top dawg]

This is trying to answer the chicken or the egg question. As long as Smith is a key to our victories, I really don't care. I'll take production either way, and Smitty is about as productive as they come.

[tight lines]

wins

[pstall]

YAC. Yards after the catch.

[CarolinaKid704]

wins

Best answer. You can tell Smitty only cares about the W. Believe me, he was having more fun puttin guys on their asses blocking for D. Will and J. Stew

in that Monday night win against the Bucs.

[Kurb]

I wish I was the guy that threw the cup at Steve Young.

There isn't a bigger pile of self-absorbed poo on the face of this fuging planet.

He is a Panthers Hater and has been forever.

[supamansmith89]

why does it even matter? as long as smith is getting his yards i'm fine.

[Delhommey]

I would like to see Smith on more slant routes. Other than that I can't complain.

[Brooklyn Bully]

I wish I was the guy that threw the cup at Steve Young.

There isn't a bigger pile of self-absorbed sh*t on the face of this f*cking planet.

He is a Panthers Hater and has been forever.

He picked us to beat the Bucs, and he praised Smith during that segment.

[Kurb]

He picked us to beat the Bucs, and he praised Smith during that segment.

I stand by my observations.

[WolfPack]

wins

Ditto