I know some of us love Gil Brandt but..

[Khyber53]

Yeah, Butler makes the list for one catch. There are others that deserved that spot.

And Norman, honestly, he wasn't even the best Panther CB of all time. Might not make it in the top 3. He certainly was nowhere near as good or as dominant as Chris Gamble.

[jfra78]

I would put eric davis chris gamble and ken lucas ahead of norman..

Sent using the amazing CarolinaHuddle mobile app

[h0llywood]

I give Brandt a break because of his age. 

[pantherclaw]

I got nothing against that list. 

 

[RetiredCollegeCoach]

2 hours ago, Khyber53 said:

Yeah, Butler makes the list for one catch. There are others that deserved that spot.

And Norman, honestly, he wasn't even the best Panther CB of all time. Might not make it in the top 3. He certainly was nowhere near as good or as dominant as Chris Gamble.

And notice how we didn't throw Chris Gamble in the trash like a stale donut...we knew what we had and didn't f*ck it up...

[shulasmyhero]

A couple of obvious misses come to mind immediately.

Charles Tillman and Everson Walls

replace JNo and Butler with those two and it's a pretty solid list.  

A few other arguments could be made for guys like, Eric Davis, Asante Samuel and DeAngelo Hall over Wright, Winfield, Sherman, etc but those are closer IMO.

[Jangler]

On 7/6/2017 at 2:48 AM, carolina-chuck3 said:

Only head scratcher is Malcolm Butler. I think hes higly overrated. System player. BB made Troy Brown a hell of a CB. 

 

Everybody else is imo better than Norman. Talib is a damn stud.  

seriously, why quote the OP?

 

WE KNOW WHAT FYCKING THREAD IS ABOUT!!!

[The Huddler]

13 hours ago, shulasmyhero said:

A couple of obvious misses come to mind immediately.

Charles Tillman and Everson Walls

replace JNo and Butler with those two and it's a pretty solid list.  

A few other arguments could be made for guys like, Eric Davis, Asante Samuel and DeAngelo Hall over Wright, Winfield, Sherman, etc but those are closer IMO.

Sherman was #9 dude

[shulasmyhero]

2 hours ago, The Huddler said:

Sherman was #9 dude

I'm completely disregarding the order of the ranking.  I don't know enough about the old timers to fairly compare. 

I think you can make an argument for Sherman to be in the list.  I'll concede it shouldn't be at 9.