I know some of us love Gil Brandt but..

[The Huddler]

 

 

there are some SERIOUS head scratchers in this list. I mean, the man is always nice about the panthers..  but now that makes me cringe a bit. 

 

Ill save you the click if you dont want to read through the whole thing. I took screenshots of the big ones..

 

 

uh....

 

 

this one may squeek in...  but ehhh

 

 

uhhh....     wahhh????

 

 

under rated.  I think is a top 5 corner of all time easy...  guess whos in front of him as an ALL TIMER

 

 

Gil...  keep the Panthers name out of your mouth. 

[KillerKat]

Writers keep making these lists without looking at All-Pro selections which would put everything into perspective. Also, many of them only have short term memories. 

[Saca312]

There's no Charles Tillman on that list.

There's no Steve Smith on his top 30 greatest WRs or whatever.

I pay 0 attention to them.

[therealmjl]

Besides, Chris Gamble > Josh Norman

[uncfan888]

Josh Norman on the greatest corners ever list? Why? 

[Jmac]

Well he had one pro bowl year.....isnt' that enough for the HOF?!!☆

Sent using the amazing CarolinaHuddle mobile app

[pantherphan96]

Too early to put Norman, Butler, or Sherman on there. All 3 will probably be top 30 by the time the retired though.

[KSpan]

  On 7/5/2017 at 10:06 PM, pantherphan96 said:

Too early to put Norman, Butler, or Sherman on there. All 3 will probably be top 30 by the time the retired though.

Expand  

I'm fine with seeing Sherman on there, though I'd have him in the 20s, but Norman and Butler are definitely premature.

[The Huddler]

Again

 

Sherman over Champ Bailey?

 

ya fugin retard! 

[KillerKat]

  On 7/5/2017 at 10:50 PM, The Huddler said:

Again

 

Sherman over Champ Bailey?

 

ya fugin retard! 

Expand  

And counting all-pros, Bailey had 7 and Sherman has 4.  And Bailey actually has 4 first team selections. Brandt is only counting Associated Press selections and only the first team at that. AP, UP/UPI/International News Service, Pro Football Writers Association, and Sporting News all count too.

[The Huddler]

  On 7/5/2017 at 11:32 PM, KillerKat said:

And counting all-pros, Bailey had 7 and Sherman has 4.  And Bailey actually has 4 first team selections. Brandt is only counting Associated Press selections and only the first team at that. AP, UP/UPI/International News Service, Pro Football Writers Association, and Sporting News all count too.

Expand  

I also feel Bailey has stood the test of time. He was top notch for a looong while  

 

i think smitty said he was the hardest corner he ever faced. 

[KillerKat]

  On 7/5/2017 at 11:35 PM, The Huddler said:

I also feel Bailey has stood the test of time. He was top notch for a looong while  

 

i think smitty said he was the hardest corner he ever faced. 

Expand  

It's also hard to put a CB top ten on any all-time list when he only covers 1 side of the field.

[The Huddler]

  On 7/5/2017 at 11:37 PM, KillerKat said:

It's also hard to put a CB top ten on any all-time list when he only covers 1 side of the field.

Expand  

Not to mention the bullsshit he stirs up with his teammates

 

Champ was a leader and an example

 

i guess sherman is a leader too but hes too polarizing. You got dudes on his own team who hate him. 

[AggieLean]

  On 7/5/2017 at 11:44 PM, The Huddler said:

Not to mention the bullsshit he stirs up with his teammates

 

Champ was a leader and an example

 

i guess sherman is a leader too but hes too polarizing. You got dudes on his own team who hate him. 

Expand  

The bold don't have nothing to do with his on field production. I don't agree with the list, but I had to point that out.