Stephen A Smith: Cam Newton will be better than Andrew Luck this season.

[PandaPancake]

Not repeat from every year since 2011.

[Silent Majority]

What would luck do with the 2015 team? One could wonder.. 

Not difficult. He would have been beat tf up and had a poo ton of passes dropped, like our Stud of a qb. Hop off of neck beards nuts.

 

[UnluckyCharms]

On June 15, 2017 at 7:12 AM, L-TownCat said:

And that destroys any credibility your argument may have had.

Not an argument and I'm not saying I agree with it(especially QBR since it's essentially made up) but he said the stats don't back it up and they actually do. You can dispute it all you want but the stats are in Lucks favor. He's a better QB, Cam is the better overall player. Nothing wrong with that and its not a knock on Cam.

[UnluckyCharms]

On June 15, 2017 at 10:35 AM, Darvinsun said:

Cam is not a bad passer..luck has just as many interceptions than Cam has. Cam can make all throws just like Luck.  Newton is not as strong are short throws that need a little air but it is not to say he can not make those throws... I say they are almost neck and neck in that regard but newton is better because of the it factor just being a baller.  I like Luck, but to say he os a better Qb and Cam is just a player is not correct because Cam can do everything Luck can do and some things better.

I agree(Luck does have 10 less interceptions but he's also played 23 less games so his turnover rate is actually higher). I wasn't saying Cam is just a player. Im saying he's a better overall football player than Luck.

[falconidae]

Think it'll depend on who has a better Oline- Colts may have surrounded Luck with weapons, but not with Oline.

Whoever's Oline can give him time to make plays will look better.

[L-TownCat]

2 hours ago, UnluckyCharms said:

Not an argument and I'm not saying I agree with it(especially QBR since it's essentially made up) but he said the stats don't back it up and they actually do. You can dispute it all you want but the stats are in Lucks favor. He's a better QB, Cam is the better overall player. Nothing wrong with that and its not a knock on Cam.

There's have been several threads on the comparisons between the two citing every pertinent statistic available.

At this stage in Cams career he is pacing the very best the game has ever seen, Marino, Favre, Manning, Brady etc.  Luck may also be doing it but he has to throw eleventy billion times a game.

Look, if you think luck is better fine.  No harm no foul, but don't expect a lot of company on your crusade.

[RJK]

I bet luck wishes he wasn't a draft dodger

[raleigh-panther]

Be better if he said Newton would be better than Rodgers this year