Jump to content
  • Welcome!

    Register and log in easily with Twitter or Google accounts!

    Or simply create a new Huddle account. 

    Members receive fewer ads , access our dark theme, and the ability to join the discussion!

     

Vernon Butler - Luxury pick gone wrong?


Adb6368

Recommended Posts

9 hours ago, CPantherKing said:

Ealy > Butler

That is all you need to know.

The entire 2016 draft is going to be lucky to see the end of their rookie contracts. I expect the same people who defended Ealy will ride Butler for 3+ seasons as a future core player and complain he does not get enough playing time to prove it.

You are so terribly bad at this.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Too early to tell. At this very moment in time, he's been our worst first-round pick since Jeff Otah. However, when you consider the baller status most of our first rounders have, that's not a huge insult to him. I'm not ready to label him a bust just yet though, let's see how he steps up next year.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I was okay with the pick all things considered with KK's contract situation, but was hoping for a different direction honestly.

Calling him a bust is quite foolish. But let's not kid ourselves, he's going to have to make some serious noise in 2017 to justify that selection. But he has to get on the field first.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

37 minutes ago, Cpt slay a ho said:

that's the beauty of the draft, cowboys bad luck with not being able to grab rice. But that also brings up the question, is Joe Montana the same qb without Walsh? Who knows great story



Sent from my iPhone using CarolinaHuddle

I think Montana just had the "it factor" and could have played in any era. That said, he and Bill Walsh were a match made in heaven. Montana was the perfect QB for the West Coast Offense.

Walsh was running a prototype of that system in Cincinnati in the 1970's with Ken Anderson. He just took it to San Francisco when he got the HC gig and took it to the next level. But, without the success he had with Montana, I wonder if the West Coast Offense would've became the dominant offensive scheme in the NFL. It's a copycat league. If the WCO had never taken off, today's NFL would be different.

Also look at what happened to Landry. The Cowboys began to stumble after the 81 and 82 title losses. If he has Montana does that happen? If the Cowboys had won a couple of titles in the 80's would Bum Bright have sold the team to Jerry Jones when he did.  Would Landry have coached longer and retired on his own terms? Without Jerry Jones, there is no hiring of Jimmy Johnson. No Herschel Walker trade which set the stage for the Cowboys dynasty of the early 90's. You would have definitely had a butterfly effect in terms of the impact on NFL history.

Makes me wonder how things would be today if just one GM had the foresight to draft Brady before the Patriots in the 6th round in 2000 (?)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

People get hung up on the "starting 22".

Based on a 4-3-4 defense and 2wr, TE, FB, and RB you need to add:

3rd DT, 3rd DE, 3rd CB, 3rd WR and 2 TE

Those extra 5 guys receive considerable snaps.

Last year DT snaps were as such:

Star 703

Short 780

Love 224

Butler 225

Soliai 152

I would guess they would really like to get Star's and Short's snap counts down some.  If Butler is a productive player in that 400-500 snap range I would say he is worth it.

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

16 hours ago, AU-panther said:

People get hung up on the "starting 22".

Based on a 4-3-4 defense and 2wr, TE, FB, and RB you need to add:

3rd DT, 3rd DE, 3rd CB, 3rd WR and 2 TE

Those extra 5 guys receive considerable snaps.

Last year DT snaps were as such:

Star 703

Short 780

Love 224

Butler 225

Soliai 152

I would guess they would really like to get Star's and Short's snap counts down some.  If Butler is a productive player in that 400-500 snap range I would say he is worth it.

 

Great Point. It's always good if you have the ability to rotate guys in and out to keep them from wearing down...especially in today's pass happy league. I loved what the Giants were able to do under Coughlin during their Super Bowl era. They could rush 4, drop 7 and constantly harass the opposing QB since because they could constantly rotate the linemen w/out much of a drop off in terms of the pass rush.

The Cowboys were able to do that in the 90's when they had Charles Haley, Russel Maryland, Leon Lett, Jim Jeffcoat, Jimmie Jones, etc

Link to comment
Share on other sites

3 hours ago, Craig Pruitt said:

Great Point. It's always good if you have the ability to rotate guys in and out to keep them from wearing down...especially in today's pass happy league. I loved what the Giants were able to do under Coughlin during their Super Bowl era. They could rush 4, drop 7 and constantly harass the opposing QB since because they could constantly rotate the linemen w/out much of a drop off in terms of the pass rush.

The Cowboys were able to do that in the 90's when they had Charles Haley, Russel Maryland, Leon Lett, Jim Jeffcoat, Jimmie Jones, etc

Very true.  Almost any team can get pressure if they want, just depends at what expense.  Problem with the that is the type of QBs that you end up facing in the playoffs will make you pay if you blitz too much.

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 4/19/2017 at 11:08 AM, Sam Mills Fan said:

Too early to tell. At this very moment in time, he's been our worst first-round pick since Jeff Otah. However, when you consider the baller status most of our first rounders have, that's not a huge insult to him. I'm not ready to label him a bust just yet though, let's see how he steps up next year.

???? Otah was a good pick...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.

  • PMH4OWPW7JD2TDGWZKTOYL2T3E.jpg

  • Topics

  • Posts

    • Man that was awful.  Completely killed my NBA fandom in a way that will never recover. I loved that Hornets team.  The Bobcats were the worst possible replacement.
    • OK, so this is a bit weird.  When I coached at Salisbury High School when I first started teaching, I used to go over to Catawba College to watch film and talk football with their coaches.  They were great. Curtis, Jalon's father, I assume, was a LB at Catawba and hired as LB coach by Bennett When Coastal started their program, they hired Catawba's coach Bennett.  Bennett must have taken Jalen's father with him to Coastal. I am guessing that is about the time Jalon was born and why he was in Conway. So then his father comes back to Salisbury after Jalen is born and takes the head coaching job. Jalen is a good interview.  I love the kid based on this, and I have heard good things from former colleagues of FB.  Salibury (when I was there) was a very rough school.  Gangs, drugs, etc.  To put it in perspective, I was there for 2.5 years and I had four (4) students in my class (at different times) who committed murder during that time. A girl was raped in the gym by a few boys.  One night, after a game (there is a road between the coaches offices in the gym and the rest of the school) the coaches watched film until 1 AM or so.  When we were leaving to walk to our cars parked across that street, we noticed a car sitting in the middle of the road about 100 yards away with its lights off.  The driver took off when we neared the street, so we all hit the ground.  As the car passed, we heard about 6 or 7 gunshots.  The next day, the van behind where we fell to the ground had 2 bullet holes in it, about 5 feet above the ground.  All that to say this:  If the young man on the video endured anything like that, I want him to succeed and I found it interesting that he mentioned playing for the Panthers.  I am not sold on the player as a fit here based on our needs, but I am sold on the person.  Very proud of him for some reason that many may not understand. 
    • First off, he's not even eligible for a contract yet.  You have to play three years. And thank goodness! All we saw last year were glimpses.  Yes, those glimpses were enough that I think every fan wants to see him come back next year.  But bottom line is that so far, with only a couple games worth of exceptions, he hasn't yet shown that he's a FRANCHISE QB.  He hasn't shown the consistent ability to elevate the players around him. He could be the guy.  After week two of this year, just saying that much is a massive, massive positive swing.  But let's see him put it together for 17 games.  Let's see him make the people around him BETTER.  Then we can talk about extending him. Let's not lose sight of the fact that thus far in his career, in no season has BY exceeded the rookie stats of MAC JONES. We should  be excited for the possibility, but we certainly haven't seen yet what we need to see to declare we have our guy.
×
×
  • Create New...