Post what you think the Panthers Draftroom Big Board looks like for the Top 10 Picks

[Ace_Aladdin]

1. Garrett 

2. Fournette

3. OJ Howard

4. Solomon

5. Hooker

6. Adams

7. Cook

8. McCaffrey

9. Allen

10 . Ross

 

Its not gonna be Safety , Defense End , or DT.  Panthers are gonna go either RB/TE.

[uncfan888]

I picture our war room and our board looking something like this. Dave, after eating the biggest cheese steak he could find, writes this on the board, sits down in the back corner and nods off

[Nails]

13 minutes ago, DaveThePanther2008 said:

Simply put anyone can put the highlights up and make him look all pro.  Got that. Video almost solidifies my question.  I saw 3 plays against the run over a course of his career.  Not counting the one where the other defender stalled the play but he got credit for the push out of bounds.

Anyone got some real counter to my question other than a hype video?

Got the Pros and Cons? 

They've been discussed at length.  He had more sacks in 3 years than Reggie White or Von Miller had in 4, the only SEC player in history to have 10 or more sacks in 3 straight years, and is top 10 in CFB history in sacks, period, in only 3 years.  He's got great intangibles and is a great team guy.  He's only 20 years old.  He played in the SEC.  He showed up biggest in the biggest games and biggest moments.  He can stop the run, not sure where that rumor started, and even cover, as Mayock raved about.

The only con is that despite having capable measurables equal to the majority of Pro Bowl DE's, he doesn't have circus freak clown show Julius Peppers level measurables, which if he did he wouldn't be in the discussion at 8.

The teams behind us including the Saints are very much hoping GMan thinks like many on this board.

[Cyberjag]

This is a little difficult, because our big board won't be like everyone else's.  It's the ten players who will improve the Panthers the most.  Note that I believe college production means more than the combine or recent injury concerns, so Allen is still up there.

1. Myles Garrett, DE, Texas A&M
2. Jonathan Allen, DT/DE, Alabama
3. Leonard Fournette, RB, LSU
4. Jamal Adams, S, LSU
5. Soloman Thomas, DE, Stanford
6. Jabril Peppers, SS, Michigan
7. Corey Davis, WR, Western Michigan
8. O.J. Howard, TE, Alabama
9. Derek Barnett, DE, Tennessee
10. Malik Hooker, S, Ohio State

[MV%doe]

23 minutes ago, DaveThePanther2008 said:

Simply put anyone can put the highlights up and make him look all pro.  Got that. Video almost solidifies my question.  I saw 3 plays against the run over a course of his career.  Not counting the one where the other defender stalled the play but he got credit for the push out of bounds.

Anyone got some real counter to my question other than a hype video?

Got the Pros and Cons? 

NFL draft profile does as good as anyone these days- http://www.nfl.com/draft/2017/profiles/derek-barnett?id=2557984

Look I'm a huuuuuge guy on arm length at every spot( even kicker! ), especially the edges for OTs and DEs/OLBs. Barnett fails there. Along with arm length, I'm a believer in game film too. What Barrent did in the SEC is nothing short of amazing. He truly isn't getting his due prasie, he broke Reggie white all-time Tennessee record. I simply cannot overlook that due to bad athletic numbers. Plus I personally don't buy the "sick" combine stuff, most thought he would test bad. I do not care about pro-days, combine is a even test for all. Pro-days are heavy favored for the players, cause they have home field advantage.

After all that, my problem is, I currently dont have someone better to replace him on #7 on my board. Plus I'm starting to believe he maybe a better fit as 3-4 OLB too.

[gmonjimbo]

1. Myles Garrett 

2. Jonathan Allen

3. Solomon Thomas 

4. Jamal Adams 

5. Malik Hooker 

6. Leonard Fournette 

7. Taco Charleton 

8. Marshon Lattimore 

9. OJ Howard 

10. John Ross

11. Malik McDowell 

 

[DaveThePanther2008]

Thanks for a more educated response.  I can watch videos and being I don't have access to the magazines that I used to read. I go by what I read and Barnett hasn't been a highly discussed player.

I think that there are many on here that like him and many that don't raises red flags for me.

It is impressive with his sack totals and eases some concerns. 

Last thing we need to do is grab an overhyped player.

[DaveThePanther2008]

10 minutes ago, MV%doe said:

NFL draft profile does as good as anyone these days- http://www.nfl.com/draft/2017/profiles/derek-barnett?id=2557984

Look I'm a huuuuuge guy on arm length at every spot( even kicker! ), especially the edges for OTs and DEs/OLBs. Barnett fails there. Along with arm length, I'm a believer in game film too. What Barrent did in the SEC is nothing short of amazing. He truly isn't getting his due prasie, he broke Reggie white all-time Tennessee record. I simply cannot overlook that due to bad athletic numbers. Plus I personally don't buy the "sick" combine stuff, most thought he would test bad. I do not care about pro-days, combine is a even test for all. Pro-days are heavy favored for the players, cause they have home field advantage.

After all that, my problem is, I currently dont have someone better to replace him on #7 on my board. Plus I'm starting to believe he maybe a better fit as 3-4 OLB too.

Exactly and the write up concurs.

Quote

There could be coordinators who view him as an early down, outside backer in a 3-4 with the ability to put his hand in the ground on sub packages

 

[*FreeFua*]

5 hours ago, uncfan888 said:

I picture our war room and our board looking something like this. Dave, after eating the biggest cheese steak he could find, writes this on the board, sits down in the back corner and nods off

Now I know why you just stick to complaining about other people's posts instead of posting anything topic related yourself.

[Manos]

Myles Garret
Leonard Fournette
Jamaal Adams
Malik Hooker
OJ Howard
Derek Barnett
Solomon Thomas
Marshon Lattimore
Taco Charlton
Corey Davis

Sent using the amazing CarolinaHuddle mobile app

[burnettwilliam23]

Lol he would have or should have been Fired if that happened, we arent and don't belong in the Bottom of the League I'm kinda optimistic about our Upcoming Draft but then again, every time things look good for us something that ruins it happens..

Sent using the amazing CarolinaHuddle mobile app

[Daddy_Uncle]

56 minutes ago, DaveThePanther2008 said:

What is the love affair with Barnette? 

From what I have heard he is a one dimension DE and terrible against the run.   Yet I see mock after lousy mock having us take him.

Am I misinformed?

yeah he isn't nearly on the level of guys like Taco Charlton and Solomon Thomas that we could realistically get

[Malt Liquor]

I'm not sold on Derek Barnette. I could be wrong but l don't think what he did at Tennessee is  not going to work in the NFL. I watched lot of videos It's just not jumping out to me

[panther4life]

1.Garrett

2.Fournette

3.Corey Davis

4.Jamal Adams

That's as far as I can get right now and I think with the way Free agency played out, unless someone trades ahead of us Adams will be there. I'll update once I've done more research.