Roethlisberger

[bleys]

any reason he isn't one of the best top QBs?

I wanted to say top 5, but I think that's a little obvious... The list may vary from person to person, but I find it hard to push him out of the Top 3....

[17+89=6]

It's hard for me to rate Roethlisberger. Whenever I watch him I see moments of brilliance, but then I watch other games where he is nothing more than a liability and his defense bails him out of his mistakes.

[KillerKat]

Ive had him at #5 for a while.

[Mr. Scot]

On a related note, the Steelers are now 1-2, with the one win being a close OT victory and one of those losses being to a division opponent.

[King Taharqa]

Roethlisberger is a top 5 QB. Underrated athlete too.

[Speed]

Probly one of the dumbest QB ever.

[thefuzz]

He is close to knocking on the top 5 door.

[Falcons1stPanthers2nd]

He's only had one above average year. 2007.

[Panthro]

He's slightly worse than Brees Manning Brady Rivers but on the same level as Eli, Schaub, and McNabb

[King Taharqa]

He's only had one above average year. 2007.

Stats wise yes. But nobody's posted more W's the last 5 years. He is not a stats QB like a Brees or a Palmer. But the guy knows how to win big games and make plays out of nothing. I'd take that over a 30+ TD regular season QB who doesnt get it done in January.