Who Are Your Top 10 Panthers on the Roster?

[Leeroy Jenkins PhD]

So, it is the offseason, and I am bored.  If you had to look at the current roster, who are your top 10 Panthers?

Not saying importance to the team, or future potential. Which players play their position the best? 

Here is my top 10.  Feel free to argue (I didn't really have to say that)

 

1. Luke Kuechly

2. Cam Newton

3. Kawaan Short

4. Trai Turner

5. Thomas Davis

6. Greg Olsen

7. Star Lotulelei

8. Jonathan Stewart

9. Kurt Coleman

10. Ryan Kalil


 

Just for fun, here is 11-20

11. Kony Ealy

12. Shaq Thompson

13. Andrew Norwell

14. Kelvin Benjamin

15. Charles Johnson

16. Mike Tolbert

17. Michael Oher

18. Mike Remmers

19. JJ Jansen

20. Devin Funchess

 

[JawnyBlaze]

Cam, Luke, TD, Short, Olsen, Kalil, Star, Stewart, KB, Turner

[Dex]

Cam, Luke, KK, Trai, TD, Olsen, Kalil, Star, Kony, Stew.

[Moorgan]

I think it could be rationally argued that we have 8 players who are at or near the top of their position in the entire NFL. From your list:

1. Luke Kuechly

2. Cam Newton

3. Kawaan Short

4. Trai Turner

5. Thomas Davis

6. Greg Olsen

7. Star Lotulelei

10. Ryan Kalil

I don't think Coleman or JStew could really be argued across the NFL...but are obviously important to our team. But if Coleman balls out again this year then that argument could indeed be made.

[caatfan]

 

13 minutes ago, JawnyBlaze said:

Cam, Luke, TD, Short, Olsen, Kalil, Star, Stewart, KB, Turner

I'd have to go with this list.

[tiger7_88]

1. Cam Newton

2. Luke Kuechly

3. Thomas Davis

4. Kawann Short

5. Greg Olsen

6. Ryan Kalil

7. Trai Turner

8. Kelvin Benjamin

9. Jonathan Stewart

10. Michael Oher

[tiger7_88]

16 minutes ago, JawnyBlaze said:

Cam, Luke, TD, Short, Olsen, Kalil, Star, Stewart, KB, Turner

My first 6 were in the same order as yours.

The only different player I picked than you is I chose Oher over Star.  Love Star, but I think he's more easily replaceable than our starting LT.

[Norway]

1. Cam
2. Luke
3. KK
4. Greg
5. TD
6. Stew
7. Kalil
8. KB
9. Trai 
10. Star

[Leeroy Jenkins PhD]

I just can't put KB in the top 10 until I see how he comes back from his injury.

[TheRumGone]

Cam

luke 

kk

olsen

kalil

trai

star

stew

ginn

oher

i based this off last year. Ginn was highly important for speed and for pr. Oher protected cam's blindside amazingly well and based off 2014 we can see how important this is. Cam is #1 because of position but Luke and cam are the same type of quality players who have leadership roles that put this team on the map (along with td)

 

[jdpanther5]

No particular order: Cam, Stew, Olsen, Kalil, Turner, Star, KK, Luke, TD, Bene

Really tough after 8.

[KB_fan]

Cam, Luke, KK, TD, Greg, Trai, Kalil, Stew, Norwell,

... and last, but not least, JJ!    Great long-snappers are under-rated!  :-)

True, but seriously, very hard to choose #10.

Debated between:  Star, Gano (was #2 in points in the league last year), Coleman.

[XClown1986]

Cam Newton

Luke Kuechly

Thomas Davis

Greg Olsen

Ryan Kalil

Kawann Short

Trai Turner

Andrew Norwell

Jonathan Stewart

Star Lotulelei

 

In that order

[dpm0409]

1. Cam Newton

2. Luke Kuechly

3. Greg Olsen

4. Kawann Short

5. Thomas Davis

6. Trai Turner

7. Ryan Kalil

8. Jonathan Stewart

9. Star Lotulelei

10. Can't decide to put Oher, Norwell, or KB here

Honorable Mention: Funchess, Shaq, Coleman, and Ealy.