Elliot Harrison's Top 5 Panthers of all time

[nctarheel0619]

https://youtu.be/GvkGp3fU7Hs

5. Gross

4. Muhammad

3. Cam

2. Julius Peppers

1. Smitty

if it's been posted, I searched and couldn't find it.  FYI.  

 

[ncfan]

Cam easily surpassed Pep winning the MVP this year and leading the NFL's top offense to the SuperBowl.  Luke has a good argument to even jump Pep winning defensive POY 2 years ago and then in conversations for it this year.

smitty easily up at #1 for what he did for this team carrying the offense so many years even when other teams knew what we were going to do with him.  

[O-Ther]

Gonna be a lot of new names on that list in 10 years

[jayflip]

5. Gross

4. Luke

3. Peppers

2. Cam

1. Keyarris Garett

[Growl]

Can #2, Gross #3, Peppers #4, Moose #5

 

If you're talking about legacy then you've do some even more tinkering. Mills, TD.

 

[KSpan]

Order is debateable but the names are right on, and Luke is quickly contending.

[Cat]

Smitty

Cam 

Luke

Peppers

Gross

[Doyle]

I think Cam gets #1 after last year.   

[davos]

Minter & Walls could be argued in place of either Moose or Gross but Gross was just so damn good. 

For this guy:

1. Cam

2. Smitty

3. Peppers

4. Luke

5. Gross

 

[Randolph Panther]

So hard to pick just 5. Olsen has to be moving up, he is invaluable.

[Smithers]

Man it's hard not to have Walls on that list

[t96]

Jeremy's top 5:

 

1. Lee Ward

 

[Khyber53]

Delhomme's passing puts Smitty and Moose on the list, doesn't get a spot. Four out of five of those guys wouldn't have gone to a Superb Owl without him as QB.

Just sayin'.

[Daddy_Uncle]

Top 5s are too hard. Try a top 10