I pose this question to all Huddlers...

[toldozer]

I'm just here so I won't get fined.

[toldozer]

I'm just here so I won't get fined.

[KillerKat]

We probably wouldn't be in the SB with Smith. He just doesn't mix well with our group. Plain and simple. That's why Gettleman got rid of him. Get over it already.

[top dawg]

A healthy Smitty, even at this age, would have made some amount of difference, from notable to substantial. Anyone who says otherwise is just hatin'. This would have likely been his last opportunity for a ring. A motivated 89 is what you want in a championship.

[Cary Kollins]

We definitly would have won with smithy. 

 

Gettleman is ok and has been lucky but the error of letting go Smith AND Deangelo is starting to show.

[blackcat]

If we had Smith AND Jimmy Clauson, we STILL would've lost.  

[hank pimple butt]

I would toward No.....but when Smutty playes Denver in 2012. him knocking Miller flat on his on ass is work of art. If aqib tried to Twist off agent 89s head, talib would have probably incurred the full on fury of that would have been ugly, and smitty might even get arrested ( would have been awesome to see him beatdown tab again) but no poor ball security.....even Tolbert I can't remember the last time he fumbled. Not tackling the put returner . so smitty might have made it better. But I digress.....

[KSpan]

WR was not the game-breaking issue by any stretch of the imagination.

[TheSpecialJuan]

2 hours ago, mrford said:

Well, he was hurt all year, so him on the bench probably wouldnt have helped much.

 

Also, Cam developed more without a true WR#1 this year. You cant discount that in your hypotheticals.

Yeah, it's really not even worth thinking about. Now if Jordan Gross was still playing........

[mc52beast]

Can he play RT???

[jasonluckydog]

Yes he would have stopped Miller from abusing Cam

[ThPantherFan]

2 hours ago, PantherOriginal said:

If we had Steve Smith for the Super Bowl do you think we would have won it?  I don't want any answers like "Oh we wouldn't have made it to the Super Bowl if he was on the roster"  Me personally I think its silly to think we wouldn't have made the playoffs with him and even more silly to think we wouldn't have still beat the teams we beat in the playoffs with him, but that's just me. Putting that aside however, what I wanna know from all of you is, in a hypothetical scenario for just the one game (The Super Bowl) would we have won?  

(All this assuming he stayed healthy)  

No.

[Sapper]

And yet the huddle is still falling for alts/trolls.

[PantherOriginal]

1 hour ago, TheSpecialJuan said:

Yeah, it's really not even worth thinking about. Now if Jordan Gross was still playing........

 

1 hour ago, mc52beast said:

Can he play RT???

Everyone knows the o line was bad... my point is we were only one big play a way from winning despite that. I believe Steve could have gotten us that. Do you not think so?