I pose this question to all Huddlers...

[PantherOriginal]

If we had Steve Smith for the Super Bowl do you think we would have won it?  I don't want any answers like "Oh we wouldn't have made it to the Super Bowl if he was on the roster"  Me personally I think its silly to think we wouldn't have made the playoffs with him and even more silly to think we wouldn't have still beat the teams we beat in the playoffs with him, but that's just me. Putting that aside however, what I wanna know from all of you is, in a hypothetical scenario for just the one game (The Super Bowl) would we have won?  

(All this assuming he stayed healthy)  

[mrford]

Well, he was hurt all year, so him on the bench probably wouldnt have helped much.

 

Also, Cam developed more without a true WR#1 this year. You cant discount that in your hypotheticals.

[jackson113]

If we had Dwayne Jarrett we would have...

[Archimedes]

Probably not.  I just don't see him being very dominant out there on the field with his torn achilles.

[t96]

Who cares?

[davideinstein]

Better argument that we wouldn't have made the Super Bowl to begin with because his injuries would have ruined the chemistry flow. But no, I don't think Steve was going to stop Von Miller and that pass rush. Still miss the guy though.

[PantherOriginal]

Come on people do I really have to edit the post to say If he stayed healthy....  I mean really, that of course is implied.  Didn't think i needed to walk some of you step by step through a hypothetical question to get a straight answer lol 

[PantherOriginal]

2 minutes ago, davideinstein said:

Better argument that we wouldn't have made the Super Bowl to begin with because his injuries would have ruined the chemistry flow. But no, I don't think Steve was going to stop Von Miller and that pass rush. Still miss the guy though.

Yeah I just feel we only needed one big play to pull it off is all, and I feel like he would have been good for more then just one.

[Kevin Greene]

PU!

[csx]

What if we had Steve Largent?

[*FreeFua*]

Just now, Kevin Greene said:

PU!

Heeeeeeeeeeee's baaaaaaaaack!

 

And he's more retarded than ever!

[The NFL Shield At Midfield]

no

[davideinstein]

22 minutes ago, csx said:

What if we had Steve Largent?

I've got a feeling him and Cam wouldn't click personality wise...

[PantherOriginal]

34 minutes ago, csx said:

What if we had Steve Largent?

lol difference is we actually could have had Steve Smith