Eagles sign Jeff Garcia WTF

[CBDellinger]

I just know what I've seen for myself from both QBs. Even up until recently, you tell me what Garcias done and what Feelys done and lets see who is OBVIOUSLY better. So your saying you trust all coaches in this league with their QB choices? Because that's essentially what you just said.

More than a bunch of knee jerk retards on a message board?

Yes. Absolutely.

[Gscottnc5]

I recall seeing you post SEVERAL reposts recently.

I have apologized for a it and have since tried to use the search tool or looked for a similar thread;)

[St. Bernardus]

Who cares about Garcia.

[Jangler]

His boyfriend does.

[PantherFanForLife]

Watched any of our games recently?

Ding Ding. Since when does salary amount = competency?

[CBDellinger]

Ding Ding. Since when does salary amount = competency?

Well, then why arent you or any other poster here for that matter, coaching, scouting for or running an NFL Team?

Answer - because you/they are not qualified to do so. If anyone could do it everyone would.

That's not to say there are not exceptions to the rule (Matt Millen) but the vast majority of NFL coaches and staff have a much more firm grip on evaluating talent than we do. The players are ranked where they are on the depth chart for a reason.

Every nucklehead out there has the same knee jerk reaction.. but the coaches see a lot more of these players everyday than we do. They know who is worth a poo, who fits their system and who gives them the best chance to win. It's their job and the good ones get paid MORE than the shitty ones... go figure.

In regards to Feely vs Garcia (& the point of my original post)... the Eagles wanted Feely also, he was their 1st choice... but we got him instead. Their second choice was Garcia. If Garcia is such an upgrade then why was Andy Reid passing him up for Feely to begin with? (Just like us.)

Obviously they know a little more than we do.

[pantherclaw]

Is amazing how many people don't realize the only offensive system that Garcia has been successful in, is a west coast offense. Do we run a west coast offense? No, we don't. Move on people.

[Jgigs]

I actually wanted Feeley more. Just for the fact I would much rather have him go out there over Kolb and it's going to take Garcia a bit to get the calls down and by that time McNabb should be healthy again....

Vick def is not ready to be a #1 and he's not even able to practice with the team yet. I'm still boggled on why he was even suspended this year.

[Jgigs]

Is amazing how many people don't realize the only offensive system that Garcia has been successful in, is a west coast offense. Do we run a west coast offense? No, we don't. Move on people.

Normally I might agree, but he outplayed Russel in the preseason. I'm just saying...

[Chaos]

Is amazing how many people don't realize the only offensive system that Garcia has been successful in, is a west coast offense. Do we run a west coast offense? No, we don't. Move on people.

This. I thought it was obvious - guess not so much.