NFL.com Rosenthal says Cam is Top Shelf

[Newtcase]

Ahead of both Manning (including the good one), Flacco, Stafford, Wilson and others.  I think we on the Huddle all recognize Cam's many doubters are ill-informed, but for someone on the National stage to support Cam's abilities above those other obvious names is indeed a nice recognition!  

http://www.nfl.com/news/story/0ap3000000546578/article/qb-index-ranking-the-starters-132

[Kuhndog94]

Isn't Rosenthal the one that said Allen Robinson is better than every player on our team before we played the jags this year?

[Pox 08]

I call BS on the list.

 

If it is going by this season...  then Dalton is way too low.   Guy has 9 TD,  1 Int,  66% completion and over a 120 qb rating.         Make no mistake,  Dalton is balling out this season.

[Lemory]

What with all these compliments? I'm not used to seeing Cam be praised so much. 

[Newtcase]

I call BS on the list.

 

If it is going by this season...  then Dalton is way too low.   Guy has 9 TD,  1 Int,  66% completion and over a 120 qb rating.         Make no mistake,  Dalton is balling out this season.

That's fair.  I do wonder where Cam would be with an AJ, Antonio or Julio.

[O-Ther]

That's fair.  I do wonder where Cam would be with an AJ, Antonio or Julio.

or even a healthy Benji

[JawnyBlaze]

I call BS on the list.

 

If it is going by this season...  then Dalton is way too low.   Guy has 9 TD,  1 Int,  66% completion and over a 120 qb rating.         Make no mistake,  Dalton is balling out this season.

He's not going to just list the ranking based on the stat sheet.  Dalton's playing well, Luck isn't.  No GM in the league would rather have Dalton than Luck, even during their current polar extreme performances.  Cam's stats probably don't put him in the top 5 or even 10 QBs, but you can damn well bet that there aren't 5 QBs in this league that could do more than he has with what he's working with.

[L-TownCat]

That's fair.  I do wonder where Cam would be with an AJ, Antonio or Julio.

Close your eyes and imagine watching (i know i know) Sportscenter.

The Panthers are fresh off a victory in which Cam Newton throws for 350 yards 3 TDs 0Ints rushes for another 58 yards and a score.

Now here is the tricky part.  Julio Jones is a Panther.

Jones catches 225 yards 2 TDs.

 

Who does SC praise? Cam? or Julio?

Go.

[Khaki Lackey]

This really wierds me out. I didn't think we'd hear anything but, "yeah, but they haven't played anybody" until we got through games 4-8.

then again, I guess the media guys expected us to be 0-3 now and they have taken notice. 

[SteeeeveO]

Rosenthal is a total hack. 

[Verge]

Luck:

5 tds, 9 turnovers, 65 qbr, 1-2, with TY Hilton, Andre Johnson, Philip Dorsett, Dwayne Allen, Colby Fleener, and Moncrief

 

Cam:

7 tds, 2 turnovers, 86.5 qbr, 3-0, with Greg Olsen and Ted Ginn

 

??????

[carpanfan96]

That list isn't based on just this season, starts going off this season after week 4.

[Jangler]

Close your eyes and imagine watching (i know i know) Sportscenter.

The Panthers are fresh off a victory in which Cam Newton throws for 350 yards 3 TDs 0Ints rushes for another 58 yards and a score.

Now here is the tricky part.  Julio Jones is a Panther.

Jones catches 225 yards 2 TDs.

 

Who does SC praise? Cam? or Julio?

Go.

trick question. Everybody knows Gettleman deserves all the credit and praise.

[beastson52]

I call BS on the list.

 

If it is going by this season...  then Dalton is way too low.   Guy has 9 TD,  1 Int,  66% completion and over a 120 qb rating.         Make no mistake,  Dalton is balling out this season.

He'll choke in the post season.... It never fails with him.