"No debate" these QBs are better than Cam Newton

[Hawk]

love these threads....so happy there's a new one every week

[t96]

The only "no debate" ones are Brady, Brees,  Rodgers, Romo, Rivers, and Manning. Maybe maybe big Ben but I could see someone making an argument that Cam is right there with him. The rest are absolutely debatable and some are clearly not as good as Cam.

[Jase]

"no debate" = "please don't criticize me or question my rationale, my frail ego can't handle it"

[X-Clown on 1]

The only "no debate" ones are Brady, Brees,  Rodgers, Romo, Rivers, and Manning. Maybe maybe big Ben but I could see someone making an argument that Cam is right there with him. The rest are absolutely debatable and some are clearly not as good as Cam.

​I agree with this, but I would swap Romo and Big Ben.  Ben has the rings and the stone cold playoff record, Romo has the exact opposite but he still puts up numbers during the regular season.  

[SCP]

love these threads....so happy there's a new one every week

Sorry I searched Canadia Today magazine for a more compelling thread topic but every article was written by some yahoo comparing and contrasting the benefits of banging a moose vagina instead of a human vagina.

[Mr. Scot]

The only "no debate" ones are Brady, Brees,  Rodgers, Romo, Rivers, and Manning. Maybe maybe big Ben but I could see someone making an argument that Cam is right there with him. The rest are absolutely debatable and some are clearly not as good as Cam.

​There's a hell of a lot of debate for Romo and Roethlisberger.

[SCP]

And by the way. who is this twit?

Some "NFL Writer". A.k.a. dude with a Twitter account.

[Snake]

Arod and Brady no doubt.

Ben sure

The rest are not better, at the same level sure but not better.

[Growl]

Why do you gush even entertain guys like this?

 

 

these obscure clowns with apparent agendas and you guys give them clicks and press they haven't earned and don't deserve

[Hawk]

Sorry I searched Canadia Today magazine for a more compelling thread topic but every article was written by some yahoo comparing and contrasting the benefits of banging a moose vagina instead of a human vagina.

​

beats the hell out of no vagina though

[SCP]

​

beats the hell out of no vagina though

Well.... Yea.

[SCP]

Why do you gush even entertain guys like this?

 

 

these obscure clowns with apparent agendas and you guys give them clicks and press they haven't earned and don't deserve

Meh, it's more the topic than the writer. Thought it would be interesting to see who the Huddle thinks ranks higher than Cam.

[t96]

​I agree with this, but I would swap Romo and Big Ben.  Ben has the rings and the stone cold playoff record, Romo has the exact opposite but he still puts up numbers during the regular season.  

​

​There's a hell of a lot of debate for Romo and Roethlisberger.

​

Maybe, but I think Romo is underrated. He gets pretty much no respect and is consistently believed to be a choker, which is completely unreasonable. I think this is due to the Cowboys' record not being good, just like people point to Cam's record when criticizing him. If they had a better defense the past couple years they could've been competing for Super Bowls and Romo would be up there with the elite QBs in the eyes of most people. He was the main reason they even got to 8-8 those years, because the rest of the team was a 2-14 team. Guys like Dez and Murray helped, of course, but they don't take away from how good Romo has played.

As for Ben, I could see an argument for him being better than Cam, but I feel people are just very high on him because of this past season. The Super Bowls were because of their D, not because of him. And other than last year he has been pretty average for the most part. Based on experience I'd say he's probably better than Cam right now, but when it's all said and done, Cam will have had a better career.

[Squirrel]

Wait where is Geno?