IF you could ONLY choose one?

[Squirrel]

It's more about the structure for me, but if Cam takes an 18 mil per year average over a 5 year extension with lot's paid up front....not backloaded, I'm taking Cam.  If he is wanting north of 20m...I'm probably picking Luke.

 

Also Guaranteed is going to be a big factor for Cam.  It shouldn't be more than 25% guaranteed for the contract.   

[TheRumGone]

they both bring a ton to the table in terms of what they mean to the team.

 

slight edge to Cam as franchise qbs are harder to come by then middle linebackers. even though this middle linebacker is a big time game changer.

[WOW!!]

Cam franchise QB is a more valuable position than mlb..

LT and Passrusher are more valuable position as well..

[KendrickPanther]

This question is pointless. We have them both. It's like that question about choosing between sex and football. BOTH, this is America dammit.

[camycamcan]

>_>

[GoobyPls]

Luke isn't even the second most important player on the team.

[PantherFanOne]

I would have to vote to keep Cam over Luke.The QB position on a football team is ma more valuable position than ML.,also Cam is still developing and his unreached ceiling is high.

[-13 Amp-]

like has been said, QB is the more important position, plus MLBs are easier to come by...

from Clausen to Cam...or from Beason to Luke...

[ThinkAboutIt]

Stupid question. 

[mc52beast]

Luke... Cuz DEFENSE wins championships

[JawnyBlaze]

Cam.  Because what pazhoosier said.  Who is NE's MLB?  That guy from Alabama if I'm not mistaken?  Who was the Ravens' when they won a couple years ago?  The Giants?  Colts?  Saints?  I'd wager more teams have won the SB in the past 15 years without an upper tier MLB than teams with one.  Only a few teams have won the SB without an upper tier QB.  Seattle, Giants, Steelers (when they won, Big Ben wasn't even remotely an upper tier QB.  these days he can definitely be argued as one).

[Gin and Juice]

Luke isn't even the second most important player on the team.

Lol, what Panther team do you watch?

[Gin and Juice]

I would shoot the mofo forcing me to pick....neither are easily replaced!

Luke will be around longer tho

[Mad_Scientist_565]

they are both first ballot hall of famers... dumb question they both are here to stay