Jarrett or Robinson

[RabidCat]

I haven't seen any reason either one of them should be kept. Kenny Moore has shown he has the confidence of the QB's, which IMO is what matters most.

Having said that, I voted for Robinson. Reason being is simple, year after freakin' year we have been waiting for Jarrett to show this "talent". I haven't seen sht from him in the preseason. At least Robinson has caught some passes.

[pstall]

this just in...Jarrett is........HORRIBLE

[Cat'sGrowl]

Jarrett has proven he can be reliable.

He needs to get consistent.

Ryne looks to be on the way out.

I'd like for them both to step up.

[njpanther]

Jarrett has proven he can be reliable.

He needs to get consistent.

Ryne looks to be on the way out.

I'd like for them both to step up.

When has Jarrett proven he can be reliable?

[frash.exe]

Jarrett has the hands and the body, he just needs to fuging use it right and play a bit faster.

[CRA]

When has Jarrett proven he can be reliable?

he was pretty reliable last year when he actually got on the field. I think he had a few 3rd down grabs.

Neither have done anything to write home about. Moore is at is a better version of Robinson based on what we have seen thus far.......so I would have to vote for Jarrett. But putting him behind Moore thus far on the depth chart.

[The Link]

Jarrett. Easily.

[PhillyB]

when has robinson missed anything tossed his way?

[Baschski]

I'm not ready to give up on Jarrett just yet. Yeah, I would've liked to see more from him in the preseason, but there are still two games left, and preseason is irrelavent anyway. If he shows up on game day like he did in limited time last year then he's OK in my book. Robinson showed nothing in '07 and has shown nothing since his return. Cut Robinson, keep Jarrett and Moore.

[jasonluckydog]

I like both I voted for Jarrett but Robinson reminds me of a possible Steve Smith type player in the future.

[PhillyB]

I like both I voted for Jarrett but Robinson reminds me of a possible Steve Smith type player in the future.

that. minus the voting for jarrett part.

[Baschski]

I like both I voted for Jarrett but Robinson reminds me of a possible Steve Smith type player in the future.

Yeah, Robinson is just lacking the whole "talent" thing that Smitty has going on.

[panthers55]

Robinson doesn't add anything unique. If Munnerlyn and Goodson win the returner roles and Moore keeps impressing it seems he has been replaced. Jarrett hasn't done much but at least he adds a skill set we don't have. Robinson not so much.

[OneBadassCat]

Robinson and Smith are similar in size, that's about it. Smith is much faster, has better hands, accelerates better and does everything better, basically he's Steve Smith. If anything Moore is closer to a Smith type considering he's been training with the man.