Peyton (One and Done) Manning

[Goondal]

Wish he would retire and we could hire him as OC

[King Schhit]

I was wrong in the late 90's about Nas becoming more of a legend than Jay-Z. Now I gotta deal with being wrong about Manning over Brady. Maybe I should root against Cam due to this annoying pattern.

[PantherFanOne]

In my opinion it is time for Peyton Manning to retire, or else the Bronco's needto release him.From what i have seen of him recently, it appears he's lost a lot of arm strengh and is not as accurate as he use to be. If i am Denver Bronco's, no way would i pay Manning  $19 million next year,it's time to move on to a younger,less expensive QB.

[KendrickPanther]

Those lobs last night by Wilson was slow as hell too.

 

Quick throws into single coverage. Peyton was overthrowing those sideline passes into safety help. Not accurate at all. The difference is obvious, but you know that.

[Proudiddy]

The way he fell off as the season went on, I suspect his body is breaking down, and due to his age, he isn't able to recuperate between games like he did in the past.

Yes, he has had a long history of choking, but I think this was less about choking and more about his body being broken down. He's done.

[redbuddha]

In my opinion it is time for Peyton Manning to retire, or else the Bronco's needto release him.From what i have seen of him recently, it appears he's lost a lot of arm strengh and is not as accurate as he use to be. If i am Denver Bronco's, no way would i pay Manning  $19 million next year,it's time to move on to a younger,less expensive QB.

 I heard The Golden Calf of Bristol was available!

[GoobyPls]

Something happen to Peyton in the last month, he lost all his arm strength he had left. The Colts D also played a great game every time they tried setting up the short passing game they tackled great and the receivers started dropping passes

[CamCan]

I was wrong in the late 90's about Nas becoming more of a legend than Jay-Z. Now I gotta deal with being wrong about Manning over Brady. Maybe I should root against Cam due to this annoying pattern.

Manning had a better career than Brady even with two less Super Bowls.

[MV%doe]

Best regular season QB in history.

It still pisses me off the year he won the SB, he was awful!! In each game just terrible had something like 3 tds and 6 its for the whole postseason, everyone keep making excuses for his terrible play. Defense won that SB in spite of 5head payton. Sure he got them there and is 12 regular season win machine. Then comes postseason and he sucks compared to his regular season plays. Playing outdoors doesn't help him when its cold, indoor indy covered that flaw of his late in his career.

[Snake]

The saying that the Colts have luck and not much else is a myth. Luck is good, but so is the rest of his team, he is by no means carrying the entire Colts team on his back.

And Manning has looked horrible, he should retire, while he is still 'almost' on top

 

Honestly, Luck is just avg IMO but his Oline and WRs are beastly. That defense is no pushover either. Still I just dont see Brady choking like Manning and I think the Pats Dominate the Colts.

[CamCan]

Honestly, Luck is just avg IMO but his Oline and WRs are beastly. That defense is no pushover either. Still I just dont see Brady choking like Manning and I think the Pats Dominate the Colts.

You're calling the best QB prospect in a whole fuging generation average. Okayyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyy then. Look, just because he spurned the Panthers doesn't mean he isn't great.

[Snake]

You're calling the best QB prospect in a whole fuging generation average. Okayyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyy then. Look, just because he spurned the Panthers doesn't mean he isn't great.

 

Just because you like to suck on his nuts does not mean he is even good. Luck made some stupid plays in that game and if not for Manning playing like Joe Webb the Broncos defense would have dismantled Luck. The only thing making Luck a good QB is a talented WR corp and that beast of a Oline that gives him 7 and 8 seconds to throw. Thats all day in NFL standards.

[CamCan]

Just because you like to suck on his nuts does not mean he is even good. Luck made some stupid plays in that game and if not for Manning playing like Joe Webb the Broncos defense would have dismantled Luck. The only thing making Luck a good QB is a talented WR corp and that beast of a Oline that gives him 7 and 8 seconds to throw. Thats all day in NFL standards.

Umm, that line was very average and the running game was terrible. His best WR all season was TY Hilton and he still put up monster numbers. Andrew Luck is that team.

[Varking]

So Luck is just good? Come on, guys. Admit it, Andrew Luck is a great QB on the verge of being elite. His team was about 19 or 20 on points given up a game, rushing yards the Colts were 22nd in the NFL and only scored 9 touchdowns on the ground. Of those 9, he scored 3. Without his running ability, the Colts wouldn't have gotten to 100 yards a game. If you can't average 100 yards a game, how can you call that offensive line beastly as I've seen posted in this thread?

Is there a lack of talent there? Sort of. Its neither as much or as little as posters here would have you believe. Fleener and Hilton are good, but would they be this good without Andrew Luck? The guy threw for 40 touchdown passes this year and he is just good?

Every time a guy went down in Indy or had to miss time, the offense didn't miss a beat.

The scary thing is 40 touchdowns and over 4000 yards and nobody believes this will be his best year.