Catch or No Catch?

[Squirrel]

good rule no catch. 

[panfanman]

The steps must be controlled. The three steps he took were more of a stumble in the process of falling. It was incomplete by definition.

[rodeo]

I thought he took two good steps before falling to the ground. IMO it should have been a completed pass. But as someone said. Karma is a bitch.

I thought last week homer call was terrible. Worst call I have seen in the playoffs since New Orleans got handed the NFC title against Minnesota.

 

He didn't take two steps. He jumped in the air, landed on one foot, then the other, as he was going to the ground. The ball hit the ground and came out of his hands. Incomplete pass.

[DaveThePanther2008]

He didn't take two steps. He jumped in the air, landed on one foot, then the other, as he was going to the ground. The ball hit the ground and came out of his hands. Incomplete pass.

I just watched it again. He jumped landed and took to steps. They made that call. So they are rignt. I feel it should have been a no call but they don't. Crappy way to lose a game but they were in that game on a crappy call last week.

[rodeo]

I just watched it again. He jumped landed and took to steps. They made that call. So they are rignt. I feel it should have been a no call but they don't. Crappy way to lose a game but they were in that game on a crappy call last week.

 

He most certainly did not, I'm watching it repeatedly in a vine right now. He jumps, then one foot down, the other foot down, then he hits the ground and the ball pops out.

[CamMoon]

He caught the ball then took 3 steps. If anything he fumbled and recovered it. I hate that rule. But its the Dallas Cowboys so lol

[KSpan]

it was incomplete. I didnt find that as bizarre as the pass interference challenge earlier. You cant challenge a penalty but GB found a way to do so. It didnt get over turned but still.

They challenged that the ball was tipped, not the PI itself. Had it been found to be tipped, the PI would have been precluded.

[SZ James (banned)]

maybe since it happened to the boys the rule finally gets changed

[KillerKat]

Clearly incomplete. Called it as it happened. There are too many rules that benefit the offense. They need something that doesn't.

[DaveThePanther2008]

He most certainly did not, I'm watching it repeatedly in a vine right now. He jumps, then one foot down, the other foot down, then he hits the ground and the ball pops out.

WHATEVER DUDE..

Doesn't really matter....

Oh wait..... That would make you right....

My bad.... Genius.

You should have posted what a dumb thread since you know it all.

[SZ James (banned)]

 There are too many rules that benefit the offense. They need something that doesn't.

 

Is that why the best defense won the super bowl last year and are the favorites to win it again?

[Carolina Cajun]

Incomplete, Media wants it to be a complete, but it wasn't a catch.  It hit the ground and clearly came out, didn't maintain control.

[Mol3m4n]

Catch and fumble.

[dave-o]

Cowgirls fans last week....   "One call doesnt make a game"

 

Cowgirls fan this week...  "BS call cost us the game"

 

Suck it Cowgirls !  You have been getting good calls for 50 years !!